News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chinese economy overtakes the U.S.’s to become the largest by jvm on Friday December 05, 2014 @05:45AM (#8703797)
> So, it's not entirely clear if China is really the biggest economy, or just by using an accounting trick called PPP GDP.

There is no objective way of measuring the size of an economy.

Imagine some hyper-simplified economies where the only asset produced is computers.

Economy A sells 1000 Apple IIs* per year at $3k each. That means it has a nominal GDP of $3m.

Economy B sells 1000 Retina Macbook Airs at $1k each, for a nominal GDP of $1m.

Which is a bigger economy? Nominal GDP says Economy A is bigger: more dollars traded hands. PPP GDP says Economy B is bigger, since Retina Macbook Airs are much more than 3x better than Apple IIs, so the value being produced is greater. But of course this also means we have to define PPP, which is extremely challenging in the context of any modern economy.

It gets even crazier:

Economy C, the government pays workers $5m total to dig unwanted ditches. Nobody gets a computer.

In terms of nominal GDP, Economy C is bigger than Economies A and B.

Re:Chinese economy overtakes the U.S.’s to become the largest by AmirS2 on Friday December 05, 2014 @05:56AM (#8703832)
In Economy C, the workers who've been paid by the govt can then purchase 5000 Retina Macbook Airs at $1k each, the govt receives sales tax, apple employees get paid and pay income tax, and apple employees then spend their remaining money buying more Macbook Airs (going by your simpification that the only asset produced is computers) ... net GDP is then some way over $10m and everybody has a computer and is employed either producing computers or digging ditches

I would suggest that hyper-simplified economies are probably not a good model for anything ...

Re:Chinese economy overtakes the U.S.’s to become the largest by jvm on Friday December 05, 2014 @06:06AM (#8703865)
> In Economy C, the workers who've been paid by the govt can then purchase 5000 Retina Macbook Airs at $1k each

You are assuming transaction costs of 0 for international trade. If transaction costs for international trade are zero, then yes, of course the PPP adjustment would be a non-op. In the real world that we live in, equivalent goods often have very different prices in different countries.

Re:Chinese economy overtakes the U.S.’s to become the largest by AmirS2 on Friday December 05, 2014 @06:18AM (#8703918)
Well, in our hyper simplified economy, the macbook airs are produced domestically - it's the only thing produced in fact (apart from ditches I guess)!
Re:Chinese economy overtakes the U.S.’s to become the largest by vidarh on Friday December 05, 2014 @07:15AM (#8704107)
They are three separate economies. If they were not, then the GDP examples makes no sense.
Re:Chinese economy overtakes the U.S.’s to become the largest by cmsmith on Friday December 05, 2014 @10:39AM (#8705012)
Except that apple doesn't want to sell computers for C$, because all it can buy with them is ditches.
Re:Chinese economy overtakes the U.S.’s to become the largest by tomp on Friday December 05, 2014 @06:15AM (#8703908)
Your example is exactly comparing the economies by PPP, without taking into account the exchange rates. The point is that if you establish trade between economies A, B, and C, people in A would figure out they can get a better deal by buying computers from B, hence the exchange rate would rise, and B$ will be worth A$10 or so. And $C will inflate rapidly, with the government eventually going effectively bankrupt.
Re:Chinese economy overtakes the U.S.’s to become the largest by jvm on Friday December 05, 2014 @08:43AM (#8704418)
Point taken, but you could imagine a state of affairs where the costs of trade are so high that the imbalanced prices do actually represent equilibrium, e.g. imagine tariffs are 100,000% and well-enforced. In the real world non-zero exchange costs are the reason why price differences across countries for identical goods aren't just immediately arbitraged away.
Re:Chinese economy overtakes the U.S.’s to become the largest by austinz on Friday December 05, 2014 @05:51AM (#8703822)
Basically, all forms of measuring GDP are 'accounting tricks' to some extent, or to be more charitable they are estimates based on necessarily incomplete data. For example, by its nature the informal sector can't be precisely measured, but its contribution to total economic output can't be ignored.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Informal_sector

Re:Chinese economy overtakes the U.S.’s to become the largest by crdoconnor on Friday December 05, 2014 @05:50AM (#8703820)
>It gets even crazier: > >Economy C, the government pays workers $5m total to dig unwanted ditches. Nobody gets a computer.

Because GDP is not nor was it ever meant to be a measure of how great your country is. It is simply a measure of the total volume of transactions (which correlates to wealth but is far from being the same thing).

Re:Chinese economy overtakes the U.S.’s to become the largest by jvm on Friday December 05, 2014 @05:56AM (#8703831)
Certainly Nominal GDP is a measure of the volume of transactions.

However, PPP-adjusted GDP is intended to be a measure of national income in real terms, or put another way, the amount of value actually produced. Which is how people often intuitively think of GDP.

Re:Chinese economy overtakes the U.S.’s to become the largest by crdoconnor on Friday December 05, 2014 @06:04AM (#8703861)
Um, $5 million to dig a ditch still means no value produced even if it was PPP adjusted.
Re:Chinese economy overtakes the U.S.’s to become the largest by jvm on Friday December 05, 2014 @06:09AM (#8703879)
Nominal GDP: $5mil

PPP adjusted: $0

Re:Chinese economy overtakes the U.S.’s to become the largest by crdoconnor on Friday December 05, 2014 @07:10AM (#8704088)
PPP simply adjusts for local costs. It does not adjust for the value created during a transaction.