News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Thank you for interface change by onion2k on Thursday December 04, 2014 @11:58AM (#8700204)
No it wouldn't. Users who paste the title wouldn't be able to edit out the least relevant section of text without pasting it somewhere else first, editing it, and pasting the resulting modified text in. It's far better from a UX perspective to let the user do whatever they want without stopping them but inform them that there's a problem at the first opportunity. Ideally, in this case, there should be some JS to input events on the entry box that highlights the text that's over the limit. With all the server side validation as well, obviously.

For an example, Twitter's entry box on their web app gives a character count in the bottom right but still lets you go over, but anything over 140 characters is given a background color of red. It's very clear to a user what the problem is.

Re:Tell HN: Thank you for interface change by 3rd3 on Thursday December 04, 2014 @12:21PM (#8700341)
Everything you say has been said already.