Re:Why Lisp macros are cool, a Perl perspective (2005)
by gus_massa on Thursday December 04, 2014 @11:41AM
(#8700095)
> Strictly speaking, macros don't evaluate their expressions at all.
OK, you are right.
A better example is a bad implementation of a short circuiting or:
(define-syntax-rule (bad-or x y)
(if x x y))
It can't be a function because sometimes you don't want to evaluate y, but in the resulting code x is sometimes executed twice.
Strictly speaking, macros don't evaluate their expressions at all.
Square is a bad example, though. Macros are not for writing function-like expressions; they're for extending (or more generally transforming) the syntax of the language. Inline functions and compiler macros are more appropriate tools for things like square.