News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tax crackdown on banks and multinationals 'to raise £5bn' by rayiner on Wednesday December 03, 2014 @07:06PM (#8697142)
I'll address this point since it hasn't been:

> What we have now is overly complex (deducting losses from previous years) and amounts to a subsidy for losing money.

Say company A makes $10m in year 1, loses $10m in year 2, and makes $20m in year 3. Net gain in wealth = $20m. Say company 2 makes $10m in years 1 and 2, and breaks even in year 3. Also has a net gain of $20m.

Say the tax rate is 20%. In any sane tax system, both companies will pay $4m in taxes over three years. So how do you handle the loss for company 1? Does the IRS write them a check in year 2 for $2m? If not, company A pays $6m in taxes over three years, versus $4m for company B.

Loss carry-forwards are not a "subsidy for losing money." They're a mechanism for getting the right answer integrating a continuous function at discrete intervals, without allowing for negative tax due. Your solution to the complexity is to just punt and give the wrong answer.

There are no comments on this comment yet.