DDoS is a nasty problem. We've received a DDoS attack that shut the entire site down for days. We can't use Cloudflare because they don't support wildcard domains without their very expensive plan. I've also heard stories from people using Cloudflare that have still not been able to resolve DDoS issues (I'm not knocking Cloudflare, they're a great company that does a really good job fighting this very hard problem, but sometimes even they have trouble with it).
I'll be completely honest and say that I have no idea how to solve this problem. It's really, really, really hard. Switching to different service providers won't get you very far against the monster DDoS attacks that some people can execute.
I swear by Route53, it is the only service I use on AWS and I have moved a lot of my clients over to it.
Which is exactly what happened in this case. It sucks to be on the receiving end of this. We couldn't defend against it and let our customers down, and that hurts me deeply. We choose one approach to defense, which was internal, and that was a mistake. We're going to work on rectifying that now.
I've been a DnsMadeEasy customer for a while (they had an outage ~4 years ago from a 50Gbps attack), but once my year is up, I'm switching to Route53. The addition of the Geo DNS Queries was key for me. It isn't clear to me why I shouldn't pick Route53. DnsSimple's unlimited queries seems nice, but I kinda like having actual scaling costs forwarded to customers.