> The hard-to-teach students need to go somewhere.
That's obvious. The criticism is that, in the current system, laws and tradition have dictated that "somewhere" is Oswald Cobblepot High School down the street, and if that school is a hole, sucks to be you. Blame the voters that didn't pass the bond issue five years ago. Or get rich and move to a nicer neighborhood.
And that last point is especially important. The rich have places to send their problem students. And they can afford to move to overpriced neighborhoods that effectively weed out at-risk students from the student body. The current system (unintentionally) creates public schools full of hard-to-teach students.
As I see it, this exacerbates the problems of rich schools and poor schools.
And one of the side effects of the current system is that rich parents and poor parents don't even live in the same school district anymore. And housing prices are both inflated and tied to the quality of the local schools, which is insane if you think about it.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/06/25/oecd-education-repo...
Anecdotally, I know several teachers. Their salaries, for their education level (Master's degree) and cost of living (NYC area, often teaching in the city), are very low. One particular example I know is a NYC public school teacher with a Master's in education and several years experience making $45k.
Many members of this community are fine with the notion that paying programmers more will tend to attract better programmers. I see no reason why we can't extend that to public school teachers.
I don't even know if I would agree that giving more money to all schools would solve this problem. What's to keep those standardization study materials companies from raising their prices to increase their profitability?
How about if we instead take apart the centralized institutions that allow testing companies to maintain monopolies on testing and standardized testing study materials?
Once again, this isn't a problem rooted in money for education. This is a problem of entrenched power structures that prioritize maintaining their power over educating children.
Why not a school with behavior experts? Wouldn't a concentration of students with specific needs make it easier to address those needs because you can concentrate those specific resources there? To take an extreme example, look at the success of schools for the deaf or schools for the blind.
Independent of that, it's also problematic because you're essentially giving up on the "failing schools public schools", by taking resources away from them.