News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Whom do you admire most? by johnnybgoode on Thursday October 08, 2009 @04:48AM (#868633)
If he is, then so did the mob revolutionaries. In fact, so did an HN poster right here in this thread:

> The French Revolution was a step forward for humanity, no matter how messy it was.

(from http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=868344)

The idea that the government should kill protesters might seem far too disrespectful of human life, but then, doesn't the word "messy" in the above quote evoke the same reaction?

Re:Ask HN: Whom do you admire most? by philwelch on Thursday October 08, 2009 @02:37PM (#869621)
That was a bit of verbal slight-of-hand, yes. I meant to imply that if you're willing to say "the ends justify the means" to kill people at Tiananmen Square, you don't have very good standing to criticize the French Revolution, because it's in fact easier to make that same argument about the French Revolution than it is about Tiananmen Square.
Re:Ask HN: Whom do you admire most? by johnnybgoode on Thursday October 08, 2009 @03:13PM (#869714)
> it's in fact easier to make that same argument about the French Revolution than it is about Tiananmen Square

No, it isn't, because your argument depends on the "end" being an escape from "absolute monarchism" into democracy. Even if you believe the ends justify the means in general, the argument doesn't work when the end result is not very good.

Re:Ask HN: Whom do you admire most? by philwelch on Friday October 09, 2009 @12:19AM (#870618)
I'm still not sold on the benefits of an absolute monarchy.
Re:Ask HN: Whom do you admire most? by johnnybgoode on Friday October 09, 2009 @02:49AM (#870766)
The problem is, it's far from self-evident that democracy is better.
Re:Ask HN: Whom do you admire most? by philwelch on Friday October 09, 2009 @03:11AM (#870780)
It depends on the monarch.