I wasnt directly suggesting it was reason to support a public plan btw. Just that it sounds pretty stinky.
I also would add that I think you've got the wrong "problem".
control costs by challenging doctors on what they bill, and at the same time not making it hard for people to get the services they need
Is never an issue over here [UK] (not just because of the public aspect).
Could a doctor in the UK prescribe an experimental treatment? Could he prescribe it and get insurance to pay for it? I bet not without a fight.
Perhaps the difference is that there, the fight is behind the scenes so the patient never knows about it (if it's rejected I bet the doctor never even mentions it as a possible treatment).
In the US the insurance belongs to the patient, so it's the patients job to handle them (with help). In the UK it's not so.
If you want quicker service then you can go private and pay for it.
In terms of experimental treatment I know the NHS may suggest it if they are unable to effectively treat you.
Basically the UK system is the American system (e.g. you can always go private) without the suck (if you're broke you still get fixed, just on a slower timeframe).
We do have this thing called NICE tho'. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/1923989.stm
NICE picks treatments based on trying to get the best results for the whole population whilst only spending a finite amount of money.
Insurance companies pick treatments based on trying to get the largest amount of profit compatible with people being willing to carry on paying for insurance.
NI is pretty cheap and the only kinds of treatments that are going to be prevented are those that are incredibly expensive, experimental or incredibly rare. You can still go private though.
Same sort of scenario for pensions, if you don't save for yourself you will still get a state pension. You will have to live on Tesco value bread even though you "paid taxes your entire life".
The defining line is: If you're a UK resident and you're not wealthy and you don't save any money you WILL be catered for: TO A DEGREE. Sure its not always fair but it has to be pragmatic at the edge cases to work at all.
The UK govt. makes approx GBP 10Bn a year from tobacco, and spends approx. GBP 2Bn on medical costs associated with it.
if you don't save for yourself you will still get a state pension. You will have to live on Tesco value bread even though you "paid taxes your entire life"
The problem I and others have with this is that the person who contributes nothing, by their own free choice, will receive far more than those who have contributed, and saved, and now get nothing due to means testing.
I and others like me have a problem with people like you who do not understand the principle of true charity. No strings attached.
Sure I agree that we need to improve the way we provide some of our benefits, there are probably too many people on incapacity benefit suggesting some (many?) of these are fraudulent cases.
However where we appear to differ is that in principle I have no problem for a single parent or someone else with "problems" being able to claim benefit. I'm happy to have some false positives if we can help positive positives. I'm lucky with my life, other people need a hand. It is not my place to morally assert how they should lead their lives.
I'm also puzzled how you think means testing is unfair. Those who have, have. Those who haven't get given. Do you appreciate what would happen to crime figures if the dole was abolished?
True charity doesn't involve coercing the donor - and the donor is free to switch their donation to another charity that does a better job!
I'm also puzzled how you think means testing is unfair
Because it punishes those who do the right thing: work hard, pay your taxes, save what you can, get nothing. And yet those (note that I said this in my earlier comment - you seem to have overlooked that rather crucial qualifier) choose not to contribute, get everything handed to them on a silver platter.
It's easy enough to implement this: anyone who leaves their free education without some qualifications needs to work for X years before they are entitled to anything further from the taxpayer.
Those who have, have
Ermm, no, those who work hard, earn. Those who don't, take.
Yes, because insurance doesn't pay for it. You can get experimental treatment on the NHS - I think it is a little more of a hoop to jump through and depends on the actual hospital your at (for example most will insist other forms of medicine have been tried first).
Here doctors are a lot less litigatable as individuals; I think that is the main reason health care is better here. Without frivolous lawsuits and insurance companies breathing down their necks.
The problem is that in the US at this time, health insurance companies are structurally evil. Evil in that they are the source of unnecessary pain, suffering and death. That they cause this suffering in the name of their 'fiduciary responsibility' to their shareholders only compounds the evil.
The unfortunate second-order effect is that it attracts the wrong kinds of people. They need software to find people most likely to cost them money, and jack up their premiums until they switch. Would you want to write that software? Like, the line of code that says,
if policy.expected_payout > policy.current_premium*0.6:
policy.schedule_increase()See my response below for an elaboration of why I use the term evil in this context. And all of the human beings involved in this system have choices as to how they can react. The fact that some of those choices have costs does not automatically remove the element of choice. The executive who chooses to perpetuate the system in it's current form is making a moral choice and should be held to account for it.
Saying the insurance companies are evil is no more informed than the people who railed at the Obama administration for suggesting that end of life care should be rationed.
The most fundamental issue is that health-care is so damned expensive in the US. That's why we get in the degenerate situation we're in now where it seems like insurance companies are the arbiters of who shall live and who shall die.
The structure of health insurance protection in the US at this time extracts almost a third of every dollar spent on health care. And those administrative costs do not contribute towards better health care, chronic or acute. And that is why I am not afraid to make a moral judgment; an industry that steals the third part of the money entrusted to it's care at the expense of the sick and dying is evil. How can we remedy this evil?
Changing to a public plan isn't going to make it better (since they will still be trying to control costs by not treating unnecessary things).
The one thing that will make it better is more integration, but then you have people complaining that the insurance companies are telling doctors what to do.
There is no perfect way to both: control costs by challenging doctors on what they bill, and at the same time not making it hard for people to get the services they need.