Re:Memcpy vs. memmove
by stephencanon on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @05:47AM
(#8686515)
It was still nowhere near as fast as a good software sequence on Nehalem or Sandybridge. The startup cost to the microcode engine was simply too high, and its handling of misalignment was very inefficient. For "small" (< 1K) unaligned buffers (which are actually a large portion of memcpy usage on a live system), good software sequences were 3-4x faster than REP MOVS.
It did perform competitively for large all-aligned copies, which are what most people tend to look at when they post "memcpy benchmarks", but those turn out to be a relatively small portion of actual usage in most workloads.
Actually, rep movsb/movsw/movsd has been at the top at least since Nehalem (confirmed with benchmarks), and "fast string mode" which does cacheline-sized copies has been around since the P6; you may be able to squeeze out a few % more with SSE (or MMX), but the much larger code of the SSE-based copy functions (especially for alignment) is often not a win overall. Intel only really started advertising that they made it even faster with Ivybridge.
It was the fastest way to do memory copies on the 8086/8088, and might've been the fastest until around the time of the 486 and Pentium when it could be beaten by other techniques; but now it seems that it's coming back in favour.
There's an interesting discussion about this instruction on the Intel forums here: https://software.intel.com/en-us/forums/topic/275765