Re:The Saddest Thing I Know about the Integers
by baddox on Monday December 01, 2014 @06:54PM
(#8684885)
What's your accuracy on a blind recognition test with a single 440 or 440.2 Hz sine wave, with no "warming up" (let's say you haven't performed the test or listened to any reference frequencies for an hour)?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Saddest Thing I Know about the Integers
by cperciva on Monday December 01, 2014 @07:27PM
(#8685016)
Pure sine wave? Not very good. A violin? Much better. My violin? Very high.
Re:The Saddest Thing I Know about the Integers
by jtheory on Monday December 01, 2014 @08:28PM
(#8685203)
Right, my wife has "piano-only" perfect pitch -- she'll recognize the key played on a piano, but if you sing a pitch (or play it on any other instrument) her accuracy goes down -- it's just based on years and years of playing piano. She can kind of hack singing a pitch (for example) by imagining playing the note on a piano, then trying to sing the pitch in her head.
I doubt she'd notice if a piano was tuned to 442 vs. 440, though... which makes some sense, really; a violinist really benefits from a sharp ear for pitch, for accurate finger placement (no frets or anything like that on a violin neck) -- but a pianist has a fixed set of keys to choose from.
Re:The Saddest Thing I Know about the Integers
by baddox on Monday December 01, 2014 @09:29PM
(#8685348)
That's interesting. My closest hack to fake perfect pitch is to estimate the range of a note my humming it or singing it. It works because my vocal range is more or less absolute, and I can easily feel how difficult the pitch is to sing by trying an octave above or below it.