News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mean People Fail by philwelch on Monday December 01, 2014 @03:11PM (#8683432)
I'm just not that interested in either proving or disproving a general statement that I don't have sufficient evidence to adjudicate either way. Plus, how would pg even argue for it? "In YC W13, these ten founders were all total assholes and their startups all failed. These seventeen founders were really nice, and all seem to be doing well today. These four founders are ok but have a mean streak, two of them failed and two are actually doing well. In S13..." See what I mean? It's not the kind of point that lends itself to data-driven arguments with publicly available evidence, and it would have been really boring to read an essay that unfolded that way (and practically impossible for pg to get away with writing it).

So what's the rational thing for me to do as a reader? What I did was to say, "I wouldn't know, but I'm curious to see where you're going with this", and it turned out he went somewhere interesting with it. Whereas you just shut your brain down because you could think of a half dozen sensationalized examples of people you've never met and missed out on getting to read an interesting essay (that incidentally also explains why, to name two examples, Bill Gates and the Uber founder are exceptions to pg's rule).

Re:Mean People Fail by modfodder on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @10:44AM (#8687642)
Actually I didn't shut my brain down, which I believe you did because of your reverence for all that is PG. The rational thing to do as a reader would have been to question his argument, but you never did, you just assumed because PG runs with founders that the scales have been lifted from his eyes.

I found his article failed the simple smell test, if it smells like bullshit, it probably is. I've read the article over and over and each time it smacks of a noble in his guarded castle talking about how wonderful and safe life is under the new king and how the generosity of the new king knows no bounds, all the while his royal cousins are massacring the proletariat.

But please, go ahead and bury your head in the sand.