Re:Math Anxiety: Why Hollywood Makes Robots of Alan Turing a...
by munin on Monday December 01, 2014 @02:55PM
(#8683315)
> The auditorium at NSA headquarters is named after him
it is named after both william and elizabeth friedman, both of whom were professional cryptographers who worked for the US government.
Re:Math Anxiety: Why Hollywood Makes Robots of Alan Turing a...
by humanrebar on Monday December 01, 2014 @03:01PM
(#8683364)
> Married twice, divorced once. Not much angst in his life.
I don't know. Every divorce I'm familiar with is dramatic enough for at least an arthouse drama if not full-blown Hollywood Oscar bait.
And I'm not sure why you would need the personality or proclivities of von Neumann to carry the entire film. The topics he was involved in are interesting and important enough for a good writer to work with. Many, many main characters are outright dull, but we enjoy movies about them for other reasons.
Re:Math Anxiety: Why Hollywood Makes Robots of Alan Turing a...
by jtmcmc on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @02:38AM
(#8686115)
Turing did many excellent things that had nothing to do with code breaking. I think it's fairly stupid to create some sort of pissing contest between which incredibly brilliant person was more intelligent than another.
So much wrong there. Polish cryptographers broke Enigma, and built the first "bombe", a key-testing machine. Turing figured out how to speed up the process, at a cost in wiring complexity. Turing never "built a programmable machine", although he conceptualized one. Flowers designed Colossus, which wasn't a general purpose computer, just an electronic key-tester, like a Bitcoin mining ASIC. At Bletchly Park, Turing was part of a team headed by Dilly Knox, working with John Jeffreys and Peter Twinn.
There's a forgotten history of electronic digital non-general-purpose computing devices: Teleregister (stock quotes), International Totalizator (racetracks), and Reservisor (airline reservations). The WWII cryptanalysis machines, and the ENIAC, all belong to that category. Programming of those involved big plugboards, not loading memory with a program. That sort of thing disappeared in the 1970s, as CPUs became cheaper. (It's back, with FPGAs and ASICs used for high-performance special purpose tasks like packet routing.)
The real inventor of the modern computer was John von Neumann, who's never had a movie about him. He's the one who insisted that random access memory, with both code and data in the same memory, was the way to go, and that computers should work in binary. His 1946 paper (http://www.cs.princeton.edu/courses/archive/fall12/cos375/Bu...) describes most of basic computer architecture, and will look very familiar to anyone who knows how a simple CPU works. In his spare time, he did some design work on the implosion system for the first atomic bomb, and, using an early computer he designed, the EDSAC, some of the design work for the H-bomb. Also lots of good papers on math and quantum mechanics. Von Neumann was a party guy, known for his dinner parties at the Institute for Advanced Study at Princeton. Married twice, divorced once. Not much angst in his life; he was a cheerful sort and had a good life. Died young, in 1957 at age 53, so he didn't get to see the computer era really take off.
Even less well known is the inventor of modern cryptanalysis, William F. Friedman. Friedman turned cryptanalysis from a guessing game to a number-crunching problem. He headed the effort that broke the Japanese "Purple" code, a tougher job than Enigma. Much of the theory behind cryptanalysis is his work. The auditorium at NSA headquarters is named after him. He was a military officer in WWI, married once. Famous quote: "No new cypher is worth looking at unless it comes from someone who has broken a very hard one." Friedman really did break some major cyphers on his own.
Neither von Neumann nor Friedman had unusual personal lives, so they don't have movies. Both were probably smarter than Turing.