Everything available digitally has a weak dynamic range.
Really? I can't find the figures right now, but as I recall the max dynamic range available to vinyl is about 40db whereas for a standard CD it's about 96db, so in the hands of a good mastering engineer, even standard CDs should be superior.Having said that, most pop music is compressed for radio or jukebox these days where all dynamic range is killed in the pursuit of loudness.
Everything available digitally is restricted by an end user license agreement
Yeah, I still buy hard copies for the same reason.A good dynamic range for a rock music recording is 15 db. Some of the really badly compressed recordings have only 5 db or less.
The best classical recordings come close to 20 db, but that usually involves speech.
None of the available formats has a problem with any of this.
Here is a link with dynamic range measurements for countless albums, if anyone wants to check: http://dr.loudness-war.info
..But, as you said the actual dynamic range is down to the original source and the whims of the mastering engineer.
The technology required to listen to a record is stone-age simple compared to even a magnetic cassette, though, let alone a digitally compressed .mp3.
The point being that if you own a hard copy of media, that media can always be read (if the hard copy is still viable), given the right technology. If you own a license to stream a piece of media, as soon as that industry actor goes belly up so does your license.
Given vinyl records last longer (when properly cared for in an archival setting) than a hard drive or magnetic tape does, I'm pretty certain neither you, nor I, nor our great-grand-children will live in a world where you can't gain access to a turntable.
There may be fewer manufacturer choices than there were four decades ago - but there are also more (and more labels pressing for) than there were only a decade ago.
I still spotify, by I vinyl too :)