Re:Wanderers: a short film of humanity's expansion into the ...
by swagasaurus-rex on Sunday November 30, 2014 @01:02PM
(#8677470)
A man named Thomas Malthus proposed an explanation why this is and will always be the case, back in the early 1800s.
Populations will always grow, even if there aren't enough resources for the next generation. As a result, some catastrophe must happen to keep the population in check: war, disease or famine.
These days we like to think that we've escaped the malthusian limit, as first world nations tend to have a naturally shrinking population.
Of course, we haven't solved any other of our philosophical vices, I'm inclined to think this isn't any different.
Re:Wanderers: a short film of humanity's expansion into the ...
by jafaku on Sunday November 30, 2014 @04:32PM
(#8678187)
> These days we like to think that we've escaped the malthusian limit, as first world nations tend to have a naturally shrinking population
Ugh, that's not how we escaped Malthus' predictions. We escaped precisely thanks to scientific discoveries and technological advancements.
Queenie: "Sorry. We've got poverty and people who are hungry here, you'll have to wait."
(400 years later)
Descendant of that Explorer: "Can we go now?"
Queenie: "Sorry, still haven't solved that poverty stuff. Go do some farming or something."
----
A lot of the "poverty and hunger stuff" is caused by corruption and unworkable politics and ideologies. Another big factor is simple human nature. "The poor will be with us always." It's a wicked problem that will probably never go away. We shouldn't use it as an excuse. (I would be quite happy trading military and secret-police spending, which is basically out of control).
Oh, we can try to address poverty. But putting everything else on hold doesn't make sense. A rising tide floats all boats; more resources and better technology will help everyone, at least a little.
[I'm actually not a big fan of manned exploration any more; it's expensive, and robots can do way better than we can, for the foreseeable future. Oh, putting men on other planets has undeniable poetry and significance, but if you want to do science or mining or whatever, you're better off with metal than monkeys].