News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mean People Fail by cbr on Saturday November 29, 2014 @02:28PM (#8674764)

    If I punch you in the face and then
    apologize to 10 other people for
    hitting you, it doesn't make me a
    good person nor have I in any way
    made up for wronging you.
If you punch me in the face and then apologize to me, your apologizing isn't enough to make you a good person or make up for punching me. So say instead you punch me in the face, and then dive into the river and save someone from drowning. While rescuing them doesn't make it up to me, it's still enough of a good thing that "gnaritas punches cbr in the face and saves X from drowning" is better than "gnaritas does nothing".

But maybe we're just getting into the semantics of what it means to "make up for" or "excuse" wrongs.

Re:Mean People Fail by mikeash on Saturday November 29, 2014 @06:27PM (#8675416)
But there's no reason to combine the two. There are two separate statements: 1) gnaritas punches cbr in the face 2) gnaritas saves X from drowning. Unless you have a really weird mutation, you can do one without doing the other. If you happen to do both, that means you're a lifesaving asshole, not that you're a good person when you add it up.
Re:Mean People Fail by cbr on Tuesday December 02, 2014 @02:29PM (#8689247)
In many real situations good and bad things come together. For example, upthread we were talking about Gates (a) doing some aggressive, mean, and anticompetitive things to make a lot of money which (b) he now donates to do very valuable things. In his case (b) really was dependent on (a); if Microsoft hadn't made lots of money Gates wouldn't have been able to donate so much.
Re:Mean People Fail by gnaritas on Thursday December 04, 2014 @10:00AM (#8699496)
> In many real situations good and bad things come together.

Completely irrelevant to the points being made. No one is denying that.

Re:Mean People Fail by gnaritas on Saturday November 29, 2014 @09:22PM (#8675749)
I'm glad someone gets it. Morals aren't math, goods don't offset bads.