News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mean People Fail by paulhauggis on Saturday November 29, 2014 @11:06AM (#8674071)
What does nice really mean?

Nice usually means you are a pushover and will go out of your way to make other people happy.

I've seen lots of nice people try to start businesses..what usually ends up happening is that someone more aggressive (IE: mean) comes around and either puts them out of business or pushes their way in to take it over.

The successful ones are the ones that pushed back or were aggressive in the first place. It's not just a rule in business, it's a rule in life. If you are too nice, eventually someone will take advantage of you.

Re:Mean People Fail by e40 on Saturday November 29, 2014 @12:34PM (#8674336)
Nice usually means you are a pushover and will go out of your way to make other people happy.

Wow. Maybe I'm just cynical, but nice, to me, means being fair, and generally employing The Golden Rule.

I've been at forks in the road many times in my business career. I always took the fork that allowed me to sleep, which meant I applied The Golden Rule. I have employees that have worked for me for 20+ years and they seem to like me.

I have no doubt that if I were a dick I could be more successful, but the cost of that would be too great for me.

Re:Mean People Fail by paulhauggis on Saturday November 29, 2014 @04:24PM (#8675132)
The problem isn't you, it's human nature.

I've worked for many companies, large and small, and it's the same. You can be the nice person, but eventually someone will come along and use politics against you (or give you unfair work loads, etc). You also won't get nearly as many raises (because nice people generally don't ask for raises), which means less for yourself and your family.

I run a few meetup groups. I was out of the country for a few months during the summer and the co-organizer (who is very nice) ran one of the groups. More aggressive people basically took over the group and nearly ruined it.

It's human nature. When you are nice, a more aggressive person will try to control you, your actions, or your situation because they see it as a weakness. If this doesn't happen, it's by pure luck.

Don't get me wrong. I'm not talking about being unethical. I'm just saying that fair and nice are mutually exclusive over any given amount of time. The reason is because someone will disagree with you at some point and perceive you as an "asshole" and sometimes you need to be an asshole to not get trampled over.

Re:Mean People Fail by e40 on Sunday November 30, 2014 @03:17PM (#8677927)
* I'm just saying that fair and nice are mutually exclusive over any given amount of time.*

My experience tells me I have to disagree with you. You can be fair and firm. I've had people try and walk over me in the past. I always respond the same way: keep emotion out of it, firmly respond in a logical way to their demand. I tell them "no, you can have/do X" and explain why.

The situation where this will not work: trolls. Public figures attract trolls and dealing with them is a completely different matter. But, in a work environment, I've never had a situation that couldn't be handled in a nice but firm way.

Re:Mean People Fail by ams6110 on Saturday November 29, 2014 @03:18PM (#8674928)
So let's say you're at this fork in the road:

On the left is a [edit: ethicial, i.e. not based on insider info, or other motivations that most people would think of as "cheating"] choice that you think will lead to more success for your business and more certainty of keeping your employees employed and maybe even hiring more. As a consequence, your competitors may lose some business and have to lay off some employees.

On the right is a choice that you think will not benefit your business, maybe this choice is just doing nothing, carrying on as before. Your competitors are unharmed, nobody is laid off, but maybe your business will not be able to hire anyone new this year.

Which choice "applies the golden rule." If this scenario isn't representative of what you are talking about, I apoligize; I am not trying to find any fault in what you are saying, just trying to clarify what you mean by what "allows you to sleep."

Re:Mean People Fail by e40 on Saturday November 29, 2014 @04:29PM (#8675146)
Your question is too vague to apply the rule. Let me give a concrete example:

I had a business relationship (he was an investor in my company) with Henry Burkhardt III [1]. He was, by anyone's definition, a serial entrepreneur. Very rich. Very successful. The following example comes from watching him.

The setup: you and other shareholders control the board. Do you: 1) use your position to dramatically dilute less powerful founders and employees, or 2) be fair and keep their relative percentages commensurate with their contribution and value?

Henry famously did #2 repeatedly. I don't have the stomach for it, so I've chosen #2. If my company is acquired, it will mean quite a lot less for me (and some other people). Is that stupid? Henry would've said yes.

To give you an idea of his ethics, see [2].

And, let me be clear: the people that Henry diluted were key to his success, it's just that he didn't need them anymore. Once the invention was made or code was written, their importance could be minimized without doing harm to the business.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry_Burkhardt_III [2] https://www.sec.gov/litigation/litreleases/lr14895.txt

Re:Mean People Fail by allengeorge on Saturday November 29, 2014 @04:52PM (#8675218)
Did you mean he did #1 or #2?
Re:Mean People Fail by e40 on Saturday November 29, 2014 @07:06PM (#8675487)
Sorry. #1. For some reason, I can't edit it. Guess too much time went by.
Re:Mean People Fail by spiritplumber on Saturday November 29, 2014 @03:49PM (#8675022)
This has happened to me at least twice (Cellbots, OpenROV).

Now I just tell people up front that I am a honest person and will keep my word to my death, but will respond to underhanded tactics with naked violence, and they can get me arrested and/or sue me iff they survive the beating (I don't much believe in weapons either, this sort of thing should be visceral and primitive).

It works surprisingly well, I suspect it's because most people who hear that think I'm kidding but have a nagging suspicion that I'm not (For the record, I am a pacifist: the last time I started a fight I was 9 years old; the last time I ended a fight was earlier this year)

I say this as someone who allowed two homeless people to move in with me and paid for their rehab, for the record - "nice" means "thinking the best of people", not "being a doormat".

Some times you have to act larger than life, good or bad, to be taken seriously.

Re:Mean People Fail by warcher on Saturday November 29, 2014 @04:46PM (#8675194)
Pump the brakes, man.

If you reach the point where physical violence is your only resort, let me promise you that, in a business environment, punching somebody is only making your personal situation much, much worse. I have been in enough street fights as an adult to recognize that they are a spectacularly risky behavior with zero upside. And are a strong indicator of something being really off in your brain. If you're really conducting yourself in this fashion, and not just barking on the internet, people will hear about it and you will get permanently crossed off lists you didn't even know existed.

Don't beat people up, or threaten to beat people up, over business deals. Ever.

Re:Mean People Fail by spiritplumber on Sunday November 30, 2014 @12:01AM (#8676038)
I agree with you - like I said, I've never started a fight in my adult life. And I don't threaten to beat people up; that's for the weak; I tell people up front "If you are dishonest with me, you will not hear from my lawyer; I will kick your ass there and then".

It speaks to the reptilian brain, and unfortunately, it's all some people (especially "mean people") listen to - which is my main point here.

That said, I have two close friends whose relationship I started with by being punched in the face and punching back. A punch is communication, sometimes (I would argue that a knife lunge, or a bullet, are not - they have permanent consequences).

We are humans. Humans, especially men, have an instinct for violence. If you can let it out by knuckles, and go home with just a black eye - it's a lot better than letting things fester and escalate, and up stabbed, shot, or having your life ruined by a bureaucracy.

Like I said, I'm a honest person. I've spent six months designing a critical part of a power plant on a handshake. I've had the pleasure of dealing with people who've done stuff like that on a much larger scale (think oilfields).

I just never again want to deal with people who think that they're better than their word.

As far as blacklists go... they're for other people. The space around me? Blacklist free zone. I've let two meth junkies into my home, live there for a year, put them through what rehab I could manage. One is clean and back in school, the other is mostly clean and working (min wage, but better than nothing). They had been "blacklisted" by a good chunk of society (yay being trans, eh), even by their own families. I don't do blacklists. And I don't let others do it to me. (You know the "rejection rejection letter" joke that floats around? I've done something like that once. It was fun and a bit of science got done because of it.)

How do I enforce this? With my hands and with my head, same as everyone else. They're the greatest weapons in the universe, BECAUSE they're the opposite of weapons 99% of the time, it's what you make stuff with.

Maybe I'm telling the truth and maybe I'm just being an internet tough guy. If you care to know, do science to it, think.

Re:Mean People Fail by warcher on Sunday November 30, 2014 @09:35PM (#8679222)
Well, ok, don't mind if I do.

"I'm self employed now, so take the following with a grain sf salt - it worked for me though. When I was dealing with HR, I made sure to growl a lot while talking, and stand in front of the only exit. There's a kind of sociopath that will only act with some consideration if they realize that their skeletal integrity is at risk, because they're the sort of people who would do that to others if given the chance. I don't beat up people at random, but you can bet that at least some sociopaths would if they thought they could get away with it - use it against them. Not to mean that all HR folks are sociopath, but you do get quite a few."

Again I say, pump the brakes, internet tough guy. Who would do this to an HR lady? Who would need to?

You have a real boner for physical violence and intimidation-- I didn't have to dig for hours to find you saying something else crazy. Believe it or not, there exist a variety of socially acceptable outlets to get your ya-ya's out against trained opponents your own size. I think (after giving you the benefit of the doubt on not just being a bullying thug, which is how you come off) you'd enjoy it quite a lot, and get an outlet for this aggression that isn't setting you back in your career.

Seriously. Try a boxing gym. Boxing is very underrated these days. Worked wonders for me, back when I was getting in lots of fights.

Be well man. You got some demons chasing you.

Re:Mean People Fail by spiritplumber on Monday December 01, 2014 @04:00AM (#8680079)
Yeah, I kinda do have some demons chasing me. Again, I've never started a fight in my adult life (the last serious fight I ended was about a year and two months ago, don't try to steal my stuff and don't bring a knife to a wrestling match I guess). For sports, I used to do fencing (and be absolute crap at it, for the record, but that's not the point), haven't found something to get into yet, boxing doesn't sound like a bad idea, thanks.

If you think I have an overarching point with how to deal with sociopaths, please address it. If you don't, heh, thanks for the safety/health advice.

Who would try to appear intimidating to a HR lady? Got me. Who would try to appear intimidating to a HR guy who thought because he could get you in trouble with the boss, you had to tell him "you are right" when in fact he was wrong? Me, as often as necessary. There's right and there's wrong and it never matters who says what, if it's true it's true, if it's false it's false.

People who think might makes right, need to be reminded that the logical consequence of that thinking is "I'm bigger than you". Sometimes the reminder has to be very direct. I abhor that philosophy, but if it's the only way I have to relate to someone because they endorse it, so be it.

And no, I don't have much of a boner for anything. Like I said, I take great pride in being honest and generous. I'm just sick and tired of people acting like everyone but them is disposable, and getting away of it because they can work the system.

You know what worries me? I say "So, I spent a year of my life getting two people off meth" and nobody cares (Yeah, maybe I'm making that up to look better. Maybe I'm not. Make a decision). I say "I am not against punching the deserving in the face when warranted" and people think that's scary. What's scary is that nobody gives enough of a damn to risk bruises. I have tried to, in my small way. If more people did - we'd see more fistfights and less shootings, police abuse, civil right violations and so on, I think.

Re:Mean People Fail by warcher on Monday December 01, 2014 @02:55PM (#8683307)
I've got two overarching points on dealing with toxic people (not limited to any particular flavor).

1) Try really hard not to be one. This is by far the most important point. You can't please all the people all the time, but really push yourself hard not to be toxic to the people around you. Physical intimidation and violence is extremely toxic behavior, which is the root of our discussion. Don't do it.

2) When faced with toxic people, get rid of them in the most permanent and expeditious manner possible. Rarely will open confrontation be your strategy of choice here. You escalate things and you find yourself with a beef taking up space in your brain and theirs, and, most importantly, jack shit to show for it. You get nothing but damage. That's a bad deal.

If you need a rule of thumb, it should be smile and walk away. Fast. Shitty boss? Smile and walk away. HR troll? Smile and walk away. Dead weight cofounder? Smile and walk away. Bad business deal? Smile and walk away.

Don't try to fix them, don't try to teach them a lesson, stay nice and get out. It might sting for a second, but over the long term I promise it will be to your benefit. I have done it both ways and my results have been conclusive. Don't snag yourself on the sunk cost fallacy. Get. Out.

Re:Mean People Fail by jacalata on Sunday November 30, 2014 @05:29AM (#8676512)
> I don't threaten to beat people up; that's for the weak; I tell people up front "If you are dishonest with me, you will not hear from my lawyer; I will kick your ass there and then".

What do you think you're doing if not threatening to beat them up? I wouldn't tell you anything in response but I'd try and get out of a business relationship with you ASAP. It makes you sound unstable, unpredictable, not worth it.

Re:Mean People Fail by spiritplumber on Sunday November 30, 2014 @05:46AM (#8676528)
FWIW, that's how one of my closest friends feels about this - he believes I shouldn't post my opinions on HN in the first place, and just build rep by writing comments that go with the local milieu.

What good would that do to the discussion, though? Read, think, make up your mind, beware echo chambers.

If you think I'm unpredictable, thank you!

If you think I'm unstable and not worth it, it's your right to. My track record should speak for itself for those who know me, and for those who don't, I'm just one more random poster on a forum.

Re:Mean People Fail by Malician on Monday December 01, 2014 @01:00AM (#8679741)
I'm not the strongest person. I probably don't have the ability to beat your face in if you welsh on a deal, and if you go nuts I'm at a bit of a disadvantage.

I do have one attribute, though. I can say "no" to someone who tries to intimidate me. The worst relationships are those with a threat on the table you're not quite sure about. I'd rather call the threat in and deal with the consequences than live with a sword hanging over my neck. Life is too short for that crap.

Re:Mean People Fail by jacalata on Monday December 01, 2014 @05:05AM (#8680242)
I have no idea what you mean. Your friend thinks you shouldn't threaten people, or that you shouldn't tell HN that you threaten people?
Re:Mean People Fail by spiritplumber on Monday December 01, 2014 @06:41AM (#8680478)
That I shouldn't tell HN that I threaten people (I maintain that I don't, but I guess it was read that way), on ground of it being possibly bad for business.

To me, honesty remains the best policy. Even if not for me particularly, a society that believes that is more robust, and well, lead by example.

Re:Mean People Fail by jacalata on Monday December 01, 2014 @11:41AM (#8681982)
For the record, I have no idea who you are and no intention of finding out. I was describing how I would react if I received that self-description in person.
Re:Mean People Fail by GFK_of_xmaspast on Saturday November 29, 2014 @08:00PM (#8675608)
Some people might call "I don't want to work at Google because a Google project manager told me to my face that my product didn't exist. So I wrapped his hand around it. It was a PCB with a lot of through-hole pointy bits, so it hurt him a satisfactory amount." (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8644321) a violent act.
Re:Mean People Fail by spiritplumber on Sunday November 30, 2014 @12:03AM (#8676040)
I would call it a very quick lesson in physics. If something doesn't exist, how can it be causing pain? It's very visceral. People can go as far as denying their eyes if facing with evidence they don't like, but very few will deny touch. An engineer ought to know better than to disrespect reality like that. A bit of pain in training, can save you a lot of pain in the field.
Re:Mean People Fail by Bahamut on Saturday November 29, 2014 @12:27PM (#8674313)
Being nice is not antithetical to being competitive or being a pushover. I'd argue that being nice is crucial to being a strong good leader.