There's Planck length and Planck time (entropic decay resolution?) to consider. If those are the basis for physical laws, isn't everything finite?
>>In some forms of quantum gravity, the Planck length is the length scale at which the structure of spacetime becomes dominated by quantum effects, and it is impossible to determine the difference between two locations less than one Planck length apart.
If the universe requires infinite computation to "go", it's doing that computation somehow, isn't it? If the universe at perceivable scale is not capable of infinite computation, but infinite computation is required, perhaps it's spawning infinite universes that do computations instantly with respect to our universe's arrow of time?
I don't understand the difference in computational requirements between predicting (in "advance") a future (entropic future) state of the universe, and predicting it JIT.
A functioning Newtonian universe must be capable of infinite computation, therefore Laplace's demon can exist (for that universe), even if only by being a copy of the universe, right?
1) a functioning Newtonian universe is impossible
2) functioning Newtonian universes are infinitely complex
The laws of physics already established 1, making 2 a moot point.
That was my first thought as well, but consider a chaotic system in a Newtonian universe. Laplace' demon must then have the capability to simulate the universe to be able to predict it. What chaos theory brings is that this simulation would require infinite precision to be done without diverging from reality at some point (and sooner rather than later as the error grows exponentially). Then you could use Cantor's diagonalization theorem to prove that no such simulator could exist, even for a finite system, because even a finite system would require an infinitely large state to represent it, and no finitely sized simulator could represent it.