I think for some people the way they presently live is the only way they know to live and so can't fathom a way to impart anything different in their children to overcome the difficulties. In other words, they're in a vicious cycle of their own culture. Religion, views on firearms, etc. have little to do with how well they do in life. It's more their culture --their way of life which they cannot escape.
That depends on what you mean by "literally". I don't think it's possible to be a young-earth creationist and still believe in education and progress. The cognitive dissonance is just too great.
But my comment was not really so much about religion per se as considering it a virtue to cling to beliefs even in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary. That applies to political as well as religious beliefs.
> they're in a vicious cycle of their own culture
Exactly right.
I have spent more than half my life being an evangelical christian where this was the dominant beliefs. Our youth leader was successful in the fashion industry, our 'worship' leader was a top-level manager at a big bank, and our members included quite a few realtors, the owner of one of the largest jewelry stores, and one of the elders (the non-paid pastors) was a high-level mathematician. I think he even won a prize once for solving some problem.
I'm not saying that there is no correlation between education level or intelligence and 'crazy fundamental religious beliefs', but your statement is just wrong.
If there's one thing I learned from my religious background, it's that humans have an amazing capacity to believe crazy things and be highly skilled, educated and intelligent. I often try to remind myself of this whenever I'm too certain of something, because if I could've been so utterly wrong once, how big are the chances that I could be incredibly wrong again?
And perhaps my mistakes are more subtle and harder to figure out now precisely because I find myself in the majority these days.
That is certainly possible. I don't know any YECs personally (thought I know a few ex-YECs) so all my opinions about them are based on what I've read. But I've read a lot, including a lot of YEC literature, because I do think it's important to understand the opposing point of view. (In fact, if you know any YECs who are open to discussion their beliefs I would be very grateful for an introduction.)
I will also say this: individual success has a very high variance, so in a large enough population you will always be able to find outliers. Notwithstanding, I don't find your counterexamples very convincing. Being successful in the fashion industry or the jewelry industry, or even in banking, doesn't actually require a lot of problem-solving skills. Quite the opposite: the requisite skills in those industries are empathy and a willingness to conform to societal norms.
A YEC mathematician would certainly be an interesting data point, but such a person would definitely be an outlier. If such people actually exist, I would truly welcome an opportunity to have a chat with one.
I do believe there's an inverse correlation between education level and intelligence on the one hand, and fundamentalist beliefs on the other. Whether they're outliers or not is another question, but I think you might be surprised how many of them there are.
Religion and politics are just a distraction in discussing their issues. The south used to be Democratic --I think it flipped Republican in the 1970s. So, really, politics and religious injection into their situation just distracts from the mindset which holds those people down.
That's right. And why did it flip? It's because Democrats passed the Civil Rights Act, and Republicans under Richard Nixon's leadership very cynically seized on the South's entrenched racism in order to capture power. See:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southern_strategy
Kansas used to be Democratic too. If flipped after Roe v. Wade, and they are only now starting to pay the economic price. There are many other examples, but Kansas is the most obvious. I don't have a reference handy, just Google for "Kansas economy". Things are worse in Appalachia because this has been going since before the Civil War.
I'm always amazed at the folks who are "open-minded" and at the same time feel a need to "correct" anyone who doesn't think the same way they do.
What is the harm if folks have different beliefs than you?
I don't think that pointing this out is in any way disrespectful.
When policy is enacted based on votes from the uneducated that flies in the face of science.
Everyone is entitled to their opinion. Facts are ground in reason, evidence, and proof, and therefore not up for debate.
(Oh, and BTW, I was born in Germany. I have been to over seventy countries. I grew up in Tennessee, and went to college in rural Virginia, and spent two years hanging out with homeless people in LA. So I'm pretty sure my "narrow mindset" is not due to not having seen enough of the world.)
The northern suburbs of Atlanta qualify, for one area. High on the fundamentalist Christian scale, higher on the gun ownership scale, and extremely high on the lower taxes scale. And all doing well on this chart, many in the top 10%.
Large swaths of the west would qualify as well.
I'm really curious to hear how your explanation for how belief in gun ownership causes people to be trapped in poverty.
But I probably shouldn't have cited this as an example because it's too politically charged. What causes people to be trapped in poverty is doggedly clinging to beliefs even in the face of overwhelming evidence that those beliefs are false. That is a personality trait that prevents people from solving problems, so it is no surprise that in places where most people have this personality trait, problems tend to go unsolved.
If you showed a climate change believer opposing evidence, they'd discount it; if you showed a climate change denier opposing evidence, they too would discount the evidence.
Because that's even more generally wrong that what you initially stated.
I also believe that, all else being equal, an individual more likely to succeed if they don't cling to false beliefs, but that's not what is under discussion here. But if you want to discuss that, there are two important things to keep in mind:
1. All else is never equal. Societal conformance is very important to success, so in a society where clinging to false beliefs is considered a virtue, an individual may well do better by doing so.
2. Individual outcomes have a very high variance, i.e. they are due as much or more to luck as a person's choices. So in a population of millions you will always be able to find individuals who were successful despite doing all the wrong things (and vice versa by the way).
All I can say at this point is that your theory is definitely in conflict with my observations of the world. So much so that I see the theory as wishful thinking about how things ought to work than how they actually do.
So let me try this again: no, I am not saying that "successful people don't cling to beliefs that have a lot of evidence against them". I am saying that a society that considers it virtuous to maintain beliefs in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary is going to be less effective at solving problems than a society that does not consider it a virtue, and so problems will tend to go unsolved more than if the society did not consider this a virtue.
What observations of the world have you made that contradict this?
You can lead a horse to water...
As long as people insist on believing that the earth is 6000 years old, that lowering taxes on rich people is going to make their own lives better, and that the best way to preserve freedom and peace is unfettered access to firearms, there is only so much you can do for them. At the end of the day you simply can't help someone who steadfastly refuses to help themselves.