Re:An FPGA Is an Impoverished Accelerator
by al2o3cr on Thursday November 27, 2014 @09:51AM
(#8667464)
"How are you going to abstract away the fact that the FPGA has exactly 2 embedded memory controllers that have precisely A, B, and C inputs and X, Y, and Z outputs?"
The same thing we do every time, Pinky: assume the existence of a sufficiently advanced compiler. ;)
Wouldn't an ASIC have hard macros anyway? It sounds to me more like the author is annoyed that "it's 2014 and we are still using HDL", and also that FPGAs are somehow supposed to be readily exploitable for general-purpose computation.
Re:An FPGA Is an Impoverished Accelerator
by reacweb on Thursday November 27, 2014 @04:10AM
(#8666517)
The same way we have 3D printers now, I would dream to have a foundry in my backyard.
Re:An FPGA Is an Impoverished Accelerator
by jjoonathan on Thursday November 27, 2014 @11:17AM
(#8667804)
Me too, brother. Me too.
It's like compiling against a binary library, except that the binary isn't another piece of software, it's an etched pattern on your FPGA's wafer. Even if you did have the "source code" it wouldn't do you any good unless you have a foundry in your backyard :-)
I'm skeptical of the calls for a higher level of abstraction. How are you going to abstract away the fact that the FPGA has exactly 2 embedded memory controllers that have precisely A, B, and C inputs and X, Y, and Z outputs? Either you come up with a solution that's effectively just as ugly as what we have now (because it exposes the FPGA's resources explicitly) or you come up with a solution that hides these details and as a result becomes enormously fragile because it's easy to accidentally change something that prevents the compiler from inferring which embedded ASIC chunk you meant to use. You need to be aware of limitations to work within them, and the limitations seem to be stuck with us for the foreseeable future.