Re:Publishing: The peer-review scam
by danieltillett on Thursday November 27, 2014 @12:12AM
(#8666081)
Yes authors should never be able to suggest reviewers. I always hated this as I knew the whole process was so corrupt. Not all journals ask for this, but it seems to have become more common.
The basic problem is that I think there is value to having referees who are anonymous to the submitter. That way, there is no problem with someone relatively new offering a strong critique of a relatively established researcher. But someone (the editor) needs to know that the referee is competent. Also, competent refereeing takes work. For example, I refereed a "methods" paper awhile back and since the method would likely be encoded into software (and there are a lot of people that don't repeat derivations), I actually went through their integrals, checked for conceptual errors, (-) sign errors, integration errors, etc. It's community service and necessary--but it does take time.