News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Monty Hall, Erdos, and Our Limited Minds by oneeyedpigeon on Wednesday November 26, 2014 @04:02PM (#8664564)
Wow - I think that's the most straightforward explanation I've ever heard. I think, to rephrase it, you're saying:

a) because a goat is revealed, swapping will always give you the opposite of what you had

b) you're more likely to pick a goat in the first place, so you're more likely to switch to a car

Re:Monty Hall, Erdos, and Our Limited Minds by hamburglar on Wednesday November 26, 2014 @04:46PM (#8664796)
The notion of revealing the goat before you make your second choice is a bit of a distraction. It becomes a lot more clear if you realize that in your first choice, you're dividing the doors into two groups: the group you choose has a 1/N chance of having a car in it, and the group you didn't choose has a (N-1)/N chance of having a car in it. Now, imagine that without opening any doors, Monty said: if you're willing to switch to the N-1 group, you win if there's a car in any of them. Do you take it? Of course.
Re:Monty Hall, Erdos, and Our Limited Minds by lukasb on Wednesday November 26, 2014 @05:17PM (#8664915)
Yeah this is it I think. If I can restate more simply for the 3-door case:

You pick. The doors are now in two groups: your door (1/3 chance) and the other two doors (2/3 chance).

The host picks. The second group is now reduced to a single door, still with 2/3 chance.

Now you decide - stick with the door with 1/3 chance, or switch to the door with 2/3 chance?

Re:Monty Hall, Erdos, and Our Limited Minds by jonsen on Wednesday November 26, 2014 @04:31PM (#8664713)
The most straightforward explanation I've heard is this:

The chance is 1/3 the car is behind the door chosen at first. The chance is 0 for the opened door. As the three chances must sum to 1, the last door has a chance of 2/3.

Re:Monty Hall, Erdos, and Our Limited Minds by dllthomas on Wednesday November 26, 2014 @05:17PM (#8664916)
That's great for defusing the "there are two options and it's random so it must be 50/50" initial of some, but it doesn't quite work for the "Monty chooses randomly, and happens to have revealed a goat" situation. I think the next point is that, when the host picks randomly, it is then correspondingly less likely that you've found yourself in that situation.
Re:Monty Hall, Erdos, and Our Limited Minds by jonsen on Wednesday November 26, 2014 @06:18PM (#8665140)
If the host picks randomly, the chances must sum to 2/3, not 1.
Re:Monty Hall, Erdos, and Our Limited Minds by dllthomas on Wednesday November 26, 2014 @06:43PM (#8665221)
Right.