News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Publishing: The peer-review scam by niels_olson on Wednesday November 26, 2014 @03:45PM (#8664481)
Um, you're talking about patenting the Higgs boson, the structure of DNA, the speed of light.

There is academic merit in being a reviewer. Being a reviewer for the New England Journal of Medicine would surely favor any tenure committee or grant application. Perhaps one could argue that's hard to perceive, but I think it's safe to say any PhD sees the value.

The journals, on the other hand, have abided by very loose business practices with exorbatant margins enabled to a great degree by the perception of the academic honor system, for a long time. Their business models and methods are thankfully coming under much deserved scrutiny.

Should researchers be honorable people? Yes. Will you always find dishonorable behavior in a set of 100 people, over a lifetime? Yes.

Re:Publishing: The peer-review scam by danieltillett on Thursday November 27, 2014 @12:09AM (#8666077)
Having been through this there is no value in being a reviewer when it comes to tenure or grants. There is value in being an editor, but being a reviewer is worth zero to your career.