News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Top Martin Gardner Physics Stumpers by Strilanc on Wednesday November 26, 2014 @01:44PM (#8663921)
> Without the distribution of the weight of the can, I don't think we can get an actual number.

Because the distribution of weight in the can isn't changing, you can treat it as a point mass as far as the center of mass is concerned. The fluid's distribution is changing, but we know how.

Re:Top Martin Gardner Physics Stumpers by thedufer on Wednesday November 26, 2014 @02:01PM (#8664007)
Hrmmm. I did a full write-up assuming that worked, and then managed to convince myself it didn't. Looks like you're right, though. Here it is:

Let's call C the weight of the can, L the weight of the liquid, and x the proportion of the can that's full. Then the center of mass is (C/2 + xL/2)/(C+L). We want where this is equal to x. Solving for x gives us x=C/(2C+L).

This passes the sniff test: for C>>L, x->1/2, and for L>>C, x->0, as we'd expect. For the given weights, we get x=0.1, so when the can is 10% full.

Re:Top Martin Gardner Physics Stumpers by Strilanc on Wednesday November 26, 2014 @04:10PM (#8664603)
The liquid's center of mass isn't xL/2, it's x L^2 /2. One factor of L for getting lighter, and one for getting lower.

I made the same mistake like five times.

Re:Top Martin Gardner Physics Stumpers by thedufer on Wednesday November 26, 2014 @04:21PM (#8664664)
In my formulation, x is the proportion and L the total weight, so I believe it would be x^2 L/2.

I also just realized that the denominator ought to contain xL, not L. My solution is a mess, clearly. The original idea is right, though.