I set them up with a really old, crappy PC running Linux. Taught them how to tinker around on the CLI and run Zork in an emulator. They had many hours of fun.
Then set them up on the Alice programming environment on the communal/family PC (running XP), and they had fun with that for a long while, too.
Once they had free internet access, my daughter discovered Hanna Montana videos on YouTube, and the self-learning pretty much ended. Ditto w/ my son and watching video game playthroughs, though he got a little more incidental learning about computers trying to tweak whatever rig he had access in order make games perform better.
However, the internet has really empowered my kids to learn all kinds of stuff. From my son setting up Minecraft servers and fighting with port forwarding on the home router, to my daughter learning sewing techniques and guitar chords online.
Today's PC environment has come a long way from my days of exploring arcane PEEK and POKE commands from the back of a magazine on my TI-99/4A (in between rounds of Munch Man, of course). There is so much more info accessible now (both utilitarian and trivial), that I just can't grouse about where most kids run with that info. In the end, I think my kids are way better off now than I was back then, even though they're not nearly as inclined to tinker under the hood as I was.
We started 3 years ago[2] and never stopped!
(We have one recurring challenge: find good tools and (French) documentation to help kids that excel at Scratch or other 'kids languages' make the jump to Python or javascript. CodeCombat is not up to it, for example. That's why I personally started a generative art workshop for young kids based on Processing Python Mode, not Scratch.)
[1] http://codinggouter.org [2] http://ils.sont.la/post/kids-code-and-cakes-coding-gouter-pa...
Haven't been this productive in AGES.
Anyway. Big segue, but reminded me of that. If I had a task, I'd have to map it out on paper for an hour or two (while, I presume, the drive warmed up)... Don't think I've ever been as productive since!
I refrained from getting internet in my apartment for the first few months and found I was often more productive at home than I was at work.
As an extra bonus, my complex had a gym with free wifi. That meant, if I wanted to watch something from my streaming subscription, I had to work out too.
All this talk of it makes me thing maybe I should give it a try again...
One of the things that I think may be going on here is that exploration now feels daunting. It's hard to get excited about getting things to print "hello world" when in another windows are bright colored animated characters engaging in absurd hijinks. However, being able to create one's own absurd hijinks may just help rekindle that spark.
I'd reccomend showing benefit first and then getting them to tinker with implementation, so you maybe want to preassemble the first one and demo it to them and let them play with it and program it once they're allready excited about the prospect of doing that.
Afterwards, I think the most sensible option would be to modify some lego 9V motors [shop.lego.com/en-DE/LEGO-Power-Functions-M-Motor-8883] to interface to an arduino motor driver shield. That way, they can tinker around with the structure of the robot as well, and legos lend themselves to creative tinkering.
Much later, you might want to get them into programming robotic arms or small quadrotors using C, but even if you get them intrested in it, it might take a while to get them to a skill level where they can do so.
In the mid-90s, we picked up an used Mac Plus for our 5-year-old. He loved it, had no problem playing the heck out of the games, negotiating menus, etc. (Although I did get irrationally mad when, as he was playing Spit on Saddam -- a local Apple guy had written it, so I'd loaded it for kicks -- he actually spit on the screen.)
So great, maybe I can start working in some HyperCard, give him some control. No interest whatsoever. I even hacked some of his games, to show him the possibilities of coding. He was amused, but still had no interest.
He got older and got the thrill of modem WoW with friends, but he still had no interest coding -- althoug I did catch him learning the warez culture.
About this time, I became addicted to browsing the state surplus equipment lot, and found that they had, literally, a pile of computers they sold at auction for essentially the cost of hauling it all away. In each pile, there were always some Macs. So I got to know the computer scrap guys and would buy discarded Macs for $10 a pallet -- and they thought I was a sucker.
To the point, the kid loved taking computers apart -- especially after discovered a PowerMac uprgrade card in a half laptop that I'd told him to toss. Nothing like an elementary kid earning $200 on eBay to keep him interested. He also helped me refurb/clone a bunch of Macs for his brother's preschool.
Bottom line: He learned how to handle the guts of computers, and to build networks from surplus routers so all his friends could come over for game nights, etc. But he never wrote a line of code through high school, despite my best efforts.
Then he got to college, decided he wanted to do CompSci. He was way behind in coding, but -- since it was a small liberal arts school -- the department was glad to have him and was patient. Plus he had some hands-on hardware skills that few others had (because the family computers were too expensive to tinker with, or no one knew anything about the innards).
He's now a gainfully employed SysAdmin, with a wife and mortgage and personal projects on the side -- and all his old pals still get together for game nights.
Maybe I wasn't a skilled or patient instructor, or maybe kids are just going to be what they are.
Out of curiosity, are you describing NJ and Rutgers? One of my close friends talks about computers auctions at the NJ state school with great fanfare when I met him in college and alas after his HS experiences in the early 2000s with his professor dad he discovered they had stopped.
My worry, though, is that I'd be unplugging the modem from the timer and hooking it directly into the wall whenever I work from home, and that'd be a slippery slope to just having it hooked up all the time again.
This would allow you to work from home, while restricting access for your children.
The only issue I might see with this setup is if your work-from-home PC is the same as the one the rest of your family uses to access the internet.
[1]: http://www.polarcloud.com/tomato
[2]: https://secure.dd-wrt.com/site/
[3]: https://openwrt.org/
Let someone else set the device password, glue the network cable into your DSL modem and the Airport Express and you are all set.
I'm beginning to see a solution in a separate computer just for Internet access, as PG suggested several years ago. The one for work should just redirect everything to localhost or not have network access at all.
I wonder if another part of the problem is that you can see other people's work online and give up when you see your achievements pale in comparison. I remember writing my first app - a web browser in VB - and when I did it I spent weeks working out how to copy and paste and create a menu bar etc. I even got joy from figuring out how to create a splash screen and create themes for my app. It was using a built in webview so there nothing very complicated about it but I had to read documentation and figure stuff out and it took quite a long time. I was very proud when it was finished. I can't imagine my feeling would be the same now. I could Google it, find the answer - ready to copy in to Visual Studio and run - and I would feel stupid for spending weeks on it. Then I would see someone who built a framework used by thousands of people on a weekend and I'd want to give up for good.
On the other hand, once I do get into the groove of real work, having instant access to the internet can be immensely helpful too.
For us that have already been spoiled by modern computing, we need to be shown what useful stuff that we can do by learning about computers (obviously we would need to be on a relatively open modern computer). If most people are satisfied with whatever gets them through the more-or-less intuitive GUIs that lets them watch some videos, do they really need to know more? Well yes, when their computer eventually starts behaving strangely and simply restarting it doesn't help... but that kind of frustrating troubleshooting doesn't leave a good taste in many people's mouth when it comes to having to deal with computers.
If they are already used to modern, powerful computing, chances are that they won't be impressed by the usual computer wizardry that programmers are impressed by. Simply because they don't need, or don't see the utility in, shuffling a bunch of text around efficiently. Instead of becoming a wiz at retro computing - which might be in part because you need to be a wiz, simply because it is more primitive - what can we impress people with on modern computers that they can't do themselves easily (and would like to do)? They've already been spoiled by modern computing - for many, there is no turning back.
If the only real allure of being a computer whiz - to most people, anyway - is to be able to operate arcane technology, then the value proposition simply isn't there for people that do not appreciate computing in itself (and even that might be an acquired taste, so sort of a catch 22). It's like a classical guitar virtuoso who can be motivated to learn songs and pieces solely for the technical challenge they pose, while his students just want to gain the skills necessary to learn their favourite band's songs, or the songs that they've written themselves.
Say someone watched a lot of different streams. Show them how they can do it in VLC from one place. Show them enough that the utility of using VLC outweights using whatever method they used previously. Then, give them some time till usage of that tool becomes a habit. Then show them how to use the VLC command line options to record and convert streams so they can download them onto say their phone. Gently suggest "There's a rabit hole here, and it's filled with fun". Then give them some time to tinker around, see what they can do. Once they outgrow these shoes, when they're running out of cool addons they can install or when there's something that's just not in there yet, you can start to teach them how to write their own additions.
Now this is just a single example, but i think it illustrates the point. You want to help them slowly build momentum and a need for better tools. Most people are cocconed in a comfortable level of software usage, and they belive that their tools are sufficient, and learning more isn't going to be worth the returns in regards to effort. If you manage to sucessfully change those beliefs, their entire modus operandi regarding computers will change.
Now what tool and which lesson will get that started differs from person to person. For some it's learning VBA scripting for work, for other people it might be using Autohotkey to create macros or even learning some keyboard shortcuts ("Wait, alt-tab switches windows? That is so neat!"). Luckily, about everything that is commonly used has some kind of handy add on that extends functionality, say Reddit and RES, or getting that Junior Junior Dev to move from notepad to notepad++ and then after a good while to vim or emacs.
Then, most important of all: don't leave them alone with it. Stay there and play with them. Maybe you'll enjoy a return to the 8-bit software development days too, just for the heck of it. Disclaimer: this worked for my two boys.
The good thing is that this could be a gentle intro to critical thinking - ie analysing a show to say what they like and don't like and why - then move on to them creating a better version for themselves... The tech skills could come later when they bump into barriers to doing what they want - eg not enough RAM or harddrive space, so they then have to tinker to get the system to do what they want.
Just an idea..
For instance, show them some of the better abridged series, and suggest that they make their own.
My parents had limits on consumer computer/TV time when I was growing up (interestingly, both drew from the same pool of time even before internet TV was A Thing). If I wanted to hop on the computer, I'd always get asked what I was planning on doing with it (and then they'd drop by the computer station later to check in on whether I was actually doing that). If I was doing something educational, like reading up on a hobby, doing schoolwork, or programming, then I wouldn't be subject to any screen-time restrictions (other than those that came with it being a shared computer).
Though to a certain extent, kids just get stroppy if they don't get their way, and sometimes they just need to learn to deal. Which sucks for everyone involved in the short-term, but oh well. :/
Here's an old blog post about it: http://williamedwardscoder.tumblr.com/post/19500788060/my-te... - I think its a fun read.
Fast forward to now; that blog post is hopelessly out of date!
I gave them old-but-decent laptops and, eventually, internet access.
As soon as they had internet access they stopped tinkering and exploring and started only using the laptop to watch repeat episodes of childrens TV.
And now they often want to use their mum's iPad - to play music and watch TV - but they are completely utterly uninterested in tinkering with any PCs.
Its sad but its true and I wish I knew what to do about it.