Emails are the original "push" and it still works. The "FWD:" is like the original retweet. Emails are part of nearly every person's life in the modern world at varying degrees.
How can Email lists not be successful? It may not be sexy, but it's real.
The beauty of the Echo Effect is that people are constantly reminded and people eventually think of your product/concept. So even if they just go to your website once, they will more likely be repeaters as long as they are given incentives to remember.