Re:PowerVR SGX code leaked
by icebraining on Sunday November 23, 2014 @06:23PM
(#8650350)
Private property is a system that's useful to reduce conflicts that arise from two properties of land: rivalry and scarcity. Ideas and other creations need to such system, since they can be shared infinitely and concurrently.
Also, the "wholly their creation" is often untrue, especially when it comes to patents. It's often just a result of having the money and/or knowledge to submit it. Multiple people can and have came up with the same patentable concept independently.
Re:PowerVR SGX code leaked
by CamperBob2 on Sunday November 23, 2014 @05:51PM
(#8650258)
Well, with land ownership, there's the small matter of the Pauli exclusion principle.
We consider it acceptable for someone to own a thousand acres of ranch land that they only visit in the summer. Clearly our understanding is not based purely on the rival nature of land.
Re:PowerVR SGX code leaked
by icebraining on Sunday November 23, 2014 @06:12PM
(#8650314)
Having the land to keep it as-is for the next summer is also a rivalrous use.
Implementing an API can still be creative. I wasn't allowed to work on Mono, as I had MS source code access. Just on virtue of having perused MS's source, I couldn't participate. I understand the reasoning, but the end result feels wrong.
Land ownership and IP are completely different, for example because nobody ever, and fortunately it'll forever impossible, paied property taxes on ideas/discoveries/thoughts.
Re:PowerVR SGX code leaked
by CamperBob2 on Sunday November 23, 2014 @06:17PM
(#8650335)
Actually I like that idea. If patent holders were required to state an expected value for their claims and had to pay property taxes on that expected value every year, we'd see far fewer stupid patents held by unproductive trolls. (And fewer outlandish damage awards since the expected value could be cited in court.)
Why?
We don't find anything objectionable about the law extending property rights to, say, land, which we had no hand in creating and will continue to exist long after we're all dead, so why find an objection to Imagination having property rights over something that is wholly their creation?
I would argue that to the extent you can morally justify any sort of property rights, copyright and trade secret more more justifiable than nearly any other kind.
Furthermore, I don't see what creative endeavor is being harmed here. It reduces the meaning of creative to nothing if you apply it to reverse engineering efforts, which are the opposite of creative--they are derivative.