Re:How to crack a master lock
by stanley_choad on Tuesday October 06, 2009 @03:45PM
(#865019)
I agree that comment sites require moderation, but HN makes every appearance of being community-moderated. The voting system is supposed to take care of the signal-to-noise ratio, and I think it does a pretty good job.
The moderation actions I am talking about, however, are unilateral (you can't even ask why), magical (you don't know it is happening), persistent (the account posts dead comments for a period of time, perhaps infinite), and arbitrary (the comments are not necessarily undesirable or contrary to the HN culture). These traits are bothersome to me, and to at least a few others. I think it warrants a discussion.
Re:How to crack a master lock
by allenbrunson on Tuesday October 06, 2009 @09:17PM
(#865818)
actually, news.yc is not "community-moderated." users have some input, but it is vastly subordinate to the power of the editors. it is them that sets the overall tone of the site. if it wasn't this way, we would have been overrun by trolls long ago.
if your account gets killed, you email pg to find out why. he will almost certainly reinstate you, if you agree to stop doing whatever it was that got your account [dead]ed in the first place.
It is a good question. It doesn't bother me. Maybe that's because I've been in the role of an ordinary user on plenty of sites with little or no moderation, and I have also been in the role of a moderator (with varying degrees of moderation power and authority in the chain of command) on various sites. Most discussion sites need moderation. Most moderation actions don't need metadiscussion.