Re:Infobitt – A movement to do for the news what Wikipedia d...
by mojaam on Saturday November 22, 2014 @03:54PM
(#8646630)
Sounds like a nice idea but isn't Google News already doing a decent job on this? It's going to be hard to beat the speed of Twitter or Google News in my opinion but I'll be curious to see where this goes.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Infobitt – A movement to do for the news what Wikipedia d...
by lsanger on Saturday November 22, 2014 @04:03PM
(#8646654)
Not really. Google doesn't summarize facts. It aggregates articles into clusters, which is useful, but it doesn't save us much time. Google also does a rather poor job of ranking the importance of stories, and often has old news for a long time and breaking news relatively late (or later than a motivated community, like Twitter, can have it).
Re:Infobitt – A movement to do for the news what Wikipedia d...
by tyang on Saturday November 22, 2014 @07:40PM
(#8647292)
Google News' strength is ranking, not summarizing facts from different sources so you can avoid reading all the top 5 or 20 articles about a story.
And, philosophically, do you HN folks really want to rely on the MSM to tell you what's important? And likes, shares and troll-ridden comments on news stories?
Or do you want a democratized way to decide, collectively, what news stories and facts are important.
Don't forget the NYT, etc. screwed up on no WMD's in Iraq.
I was at a small group dinner with Judith Miller, ex-NYT, who's nice but she messed up.
Who's checking the mainstream media?