News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Parallel Programming and Optimization with Intel Xeon Phi... by acqq on Saturday November 22, 2014 @09:22AM (#8645573)
Interestingly, Xeon Phi processors draw between 200 and 300 W alone, cost between under 2000 and up to 5000 USD.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xeon_Phi

The cheapest one has 57 cores, 28.5 MB L2 cache, up to 6 GB RAM but 240 GB/s RAM bandwidth over 12 channels:

http://ark.intel.com/products/75797/Intel-Xeon-Phi-Coprocess...

Anybody knows some "prosumer" product (and its price when equipped with 6 GB) that uses Xeon Phi?

Re:Parallel Programming and Optimization with Intel Xeon Phi... by sspiff on Saturday November 22, 2014 @12:00PM (#8645972)
I recently ordered a Xeon Phi 31S1P. They're under $200 at the moment[1]. The biggest problem I have is that you can't just plug them into any computer like you would a graphics card. You need a compatible motherboard, and those tend to be in the high price range and 2011 sockets (which means expensive CPU). Most of the time, you won't find out if a board is compatible until you plug a card in and try it out.

I'm curious how well the card will work, I'd love to see something like Erlang on such a thing.

[1] https://software.intel.com/en-us/articles/special-promotion-...

Re:Parallel Programming and Optimization with Intel Xeon Phi... by nkurz on Saturday November 22, 2014 @01:42PM (#8646250)
I've stared at that promotion (and even submitted it here, I think) but I haven't really understood it. Who did you end up buying from? Are there limitations on who can participate? How are you going to deal with the passive cooling aspect?
Re:Parallel Programming and Optimization with Intel Xeon Phi... by sspiff on Tuesday November 25, 2014 @05:54AM (#8657196)
Colfax International. No restrictions, although they can't ship to Europe unless you have a DHL/FedEx/UPS/... freight collect account.

They've been very helpful, agreed to ship the cards to a friend in the US, and were patient as my bank blocked my credit card twice because of the "suspicious" transaction. I ended up wiring the money instead.

I ended up paying 492 euros for 3 cards (2 of my friends also ordered one).

I'm just an individual enthousiast, and my friends are researchers at the local university. You don't need a company, you don't need to order a lot of them, you can just order a single card as a private individual.

Re:Parallel Programming and Optimization with Intel Xeon Phi... by iamsalman on Saturday November 22, 2014 @09:40AM (#8645600)
The whole premise behind introducing Phi to compete with discrete GPUs from NVIDIA/AMD was to have a plug-in accelerator which supports x86 which meant no code porting needed, hence enabling companies with millions of man hours invested in their code to simply take benefit of the accelerator. However, this is not the case -- The price/performance ratio for code which is not optimized to make use of massively parallel processors would be mediocre at best.

Besides, Xeon Phi's are reincarnation of project Larrabe which never took off.

If you have to end up optimizing your code for accelerators in any case, x86 or not -- you are better off optimizing it for GPUs instead.

Re:Parallel Programming and Optimization with Intel Xeon Phi... by acqq on Saturday November 22, 2014 @09:57AM (#8645639)
You are right, I was interested exactly for the possibility that even the code that isn't particularly customized for the coprocessor would benefit from using all the cores. I always believed the GPU code doesn't do well with a lot of branches, and I hoped that Phi would better run such code than GPUs. Now searching, here's Nvidia's take:

http://www.nvidia.com/object/justthefacts.html

Re:Parallel Programming and Optimization with Intel Xeon Phi... by rasz_pl on Saturday November 22, 2014 @10:08AM (#8645665)
From what I read a long time ago Phi has the same branch limitation - it can do branches by running same code twice, just like Cuda.

not to mention "x86 compatibility as a bouns" is a tired old BS line Intel uses on clueless decision makers at the golf club, it never amounts to anything, its not like you are going to just drop your binaries in there.

Re:Parallel Programming and Optimization with Intel Xeon Phi... by sspiff on Saturday November 22, 2014 @12:06PM (#8645994)
Not true. The cores run independant threads and processes on an embedded Linux system that's running on the card, meaning they're much easier to program, and they allow porting of existing software without completely going back to the drawing board.
Re:Parallel Programming and Optimization with Intel Xeon Phi... by daniel-cussen on Saturday November 22, 2014 @10:18AM (#8645687)
> From what I read a long time ago Phi has the same branch limitation - it can do branches by running same code twice, just like Cuda.

I'm fairly sure that's not the case now. Certainly the capability is there for it to do independent branches--just look at the GA144, which while limited in other ways, can have its 144 computers branching all over the place simultaneously. No, I'm pretty sure that's the whole point of this type of architecture: to allow more branching.

If it didn't, I'd be a little bit screwed, because I was counting on it for a compute-bound algorithm that really needs that branching.

Re:Parallel Programming and Optimization with Intel Xeon Phi... by sspiff on Saturday November 22, 2014 @12:04PM (#8645987)
It's not the case. These are 57 independant cores, much like you'd see in a quad core CPU, except that they're Pentium-vintage feature wise (with the addition of some modern vector instructions and SMT).

As far as I can tell, they're not binary compatible with existing software and software need recompilation, using Intels compilers.