Re:Automation Makes Us Dumb
by gumby on Saturday November 22, 2014 @02:00AM
(#8645012)
To misquote Cicero: O tempora o artis! Or if you want to go farther back, refer to the Phaedrus, when Socrates attacks writing (by citing Egyptian criticism as precedent!).
The fact is, since the invention of the water wheel automation has allowed us to become physically weaker. Some choose to work on their strength, others choose to use their time elsewhere (when in the past there was no choice). And this automation has liberated those who are not strong at all.
The same is true of the computer. There is nothing preventing you from developing the memory skills preliterate societies required, and there are even contests today of people who have honed (and probably improved) those skills.
Of course there are areas in which particular contemporary human skills will continue to be valued (perhaps plane piloting, until automation becomes good enough; perhaps piano playing simply because some people will prefer a human at the keyboard). But most such skills will be pursued for fun. I still like writing PDP-10 machine code from time to time but I hardly consider it a practical art at this point.
Instead people will continue to use the computer to extend human capability just as rockets allow people to "jump" higher than they could on their own. The "human-centered design" (as described by Carr, who should be ashamed of himself because he certainly knows better) is simply a condescending school of design. What's truly human centered is using technology to allow people to do what they want, whether it's to explore space or to write more bad memos and bad buildings, or simply passively watch more television.
The fact is, since the invention of the water wheel automation has allowed us to become physically weaker. Some choose to work on their strength, others choose to use their time elsewhere (when in the past there was no choice). And this automation has liberated those who are not strong at all.
The same is true of the computer. There is nothing preventing you from developing the memory skills preliterate societies required, and there are even contests today of people who have honed (and probably improved) those skills.
Of course there are areas in which particular contemporary human skills will continue to be valued (perhaps plane piloting, until automation becomes good enough; perhaps piano playing simply because some people will prefer a human at the keyboard). But most such skills will be pursued for fun. I still like writing PDP-10 machine code from time to time but I hardly consider it a practical art at this point.
Instead people will continue to use the computer to extend human capability just as rockets allow people to "jump" higher than they could on their own. The "human-centered design" (as described by Carr, who should be ashamed of himself because he certainly knows better) is simply a condescending school of design. What's truly human centered is using technology to allow people to do what they want, whether it's to explore space or to write more bad memos and bad buildings, or simply passively watch more television.