News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Artificial Intelligence, Really, Is Pseudo-Intelligence by tensor on Friday November 21, 2014 @11:19PM (#8644722)
Why is the brain the benchmark for "intelligence"? We already have machines that can run circles around the brain on very complex reasoning tasks. True, we don't have a talking robot that simulates humans, but in many other tasks we've met or exceeded what humans can do.

I would argue that we already have intelligent machines. What we don't have is a human simulator.

Re:Artificial Intelligence, Really, Is Pseudo-Intelligence by baddox on Friday November 21, 2014 @11:55PM (#8644781)
Haven't you heard? At the moment a computer exists which can outperform a human mind at a certain task, that task can no longer be considered a criterion for intelligence. Multiplying large numbers doesn't require intelligence. Chess doesn't require intelligence. Facial recognition doesn't require intelligence. Proving mathematical theorems doesn't require intelligence.
Re:Artificial Intelligence, Really, Is Pseudo-Intelligence by brianberns on Saturday November 22, 2014 @12:12AM (#8644819)
There's a widely-accepted standard for judging intelligence called the Turing Test. Computers are still a long way from passing that test.
Re:Artificial Intelligence, Really, Is Pseudo-Intelligence by nl on Saturday November 22, 2014 @12:17AM (#8644829)
They aren't that far from passing it actually.

One kinda sorta passed it earlier this year, by pretending to be a 13 yo boy. It was at the annual Turing Test event though[1].

Even if we ignore that, given the recent interest in using RNNs to generate natural language I'd say we are 18 months from being able to pass it reliably.

[1]http://www.reading.ac.uk/news-and-events/releases/PR583836.a...

Re:Artificial Intelligence, Really, Is Pseudo-Intelligence by plikan13 on Saturday November 22, 2014 @02:45AM (#8645080)
I strongly doubt this. Here's a good way to defeat any computer in a Turing test: tell a joke, and ask it to explain why it is funny.
Re:Artificial Intelligence, Really, Is Pseudo-Intelligence by nl on Saturday November 22, 2014 @02:59AM (#8645105)
Re:Artificial Intelligence, Really, Is Pseudo-Intelligence by baddox on Saturday November 22, 2014 @01:28AM (#8644967)
The Turing test is a method for judging whether a computer has intelligence comparable to that of a human, or what's often called "strong AI." Strong AI is obviously a special case of AI, but most AI research isn't even particularly interested in developing a strong AI.
Re:Artificial Intelligence, Really, Is Pseudo-Intelligence by waps on Saturday November 22, 2014 @02:33AM (#8645065)
Ah come on. AI algorithms

1) have passed the turing test, then, indeed, we make the turing test more difficult.

(I would argue that if you give an accurate definition of a Turing test, namely "convince, on occasion, a human that you're human", that Eliza passed it in the 1960s)

2) several industries depend on their programs passing some sort of turing test every single day (ie. outsmarting humans directly, or outsmarting "are you a human" tests, automated or no). Examples : HFT (and HFT-like industries, like loan appraisal, credit validation, insurance brokering, ...), Spamming, police chatbots ("Lolita", a US version and "Sweetie", a British equivalent), Anti-spam, anti-HFT companies (who, for example, execute share buybacks for large companies), important parts of police work, ...

3) Some things are so AI-driven that nobody in their right mind still does it manually, or at least it is globally agreed that doing things manually results in a large competitive disadvantage (e.g. shipping).

4) There are places where the replacement of humans with AI has enabled new modes of operation that can not exist without AI. UAV's being the big obvious example, but I would argue there's a better one. AI has enabled bigger ships. Most of the 50000 ton + container ships have a turn radius of 50+ kilometers. If you don't have clear vision 20 kilometers out, you cannot control these ships safely (just look for the yearly demonstration disaster of that fact in the Channel between Britain and France/Belgium). Then we started building 650000 ton ships. When it comes to planes, it's not just UAVs that cannot be controlled by humans, but several kinds of fundamentally unstable planes have started flying, the big example being flying wing aircraft. But there's plenty of others : UAVs, dynamic wing aircraft (like a bird or insect would be a good description), aircraft too light to have a human control them, ...

Let's be fair here : this war was lost, a few years ago. Nobody seems interested in giving an AI a datacenter's worth of resources just to have it figure out how to benefit itself/improve itself. If someone did this, for a few years an algorithm could learn to quite literally be a human.

Re:Artificial Intelligence, Really, Is Pseudo-Intelligence by nyrulez on Friday November 21, 2014 @11:44PM (#8644766)
You raise a valid point but for an orthogonal question. When I first saw a calculator, as a 5 year old, I thought it was the most amazing and intelligent thing ever.

The original point discussed above was about how unnecessarily complex the brain is if its function/intelligence is so simple. We may or may not want to treat it as a benchmark, but the fact remains nobody understands it or can mimic its function even after trying for a very long time. (though believe me you, that's what most of AI is trying to do, even if in a simplistic way)

Re:Artificial Intelligence, Really, Is Pseudo-Intelligence by bejuizb123 on Friday November 21, 2014 @11:35PM (#8644755)
It is not a benchmark but a target to be reached. Once we have models of human simulation, we can treat the human brain as a benchmark.