Re:Julia Package Ecosystem Pulse
by CyberDildonics on Friday November 21, 2014 @12:53PM
(#8642364)
So what are the module systems you like and what do you like about them?
I really like Python - I think forcing people into using a certain directory structure is nice, and it makes browsing code easy.
I think it's largely a matter of taste though! I just think that having a directory layout that reflects the code structure makes it easy to browse things at a glance, provided there's not too much magic in the __init__ files.
Re:Julia Package Ecosystem Pulse
by StefanKarpinski on Friday November 21, 2014 @04:52PM
(#8643581)
That structure makes sense in class-based single-dispatch o.o. languages like Python and Java. It does not make sense in a classless multiple dispatch language like Julia.
I think this is clever in the abstract, but in practice, it's a lot of headache for very, very little gain and a lot of added confusion.
The main Julia team is a bunch of incredibly smart and dedicated guys who know a lot more about designing language than I do, but I think this was a case of trying to be too clever for your own good.