Re:Rules for Creating Gorgeous UI, Part 2
by scott_s on Thursday November 20, 2014 @11:39AM
(#8636577)
I think you're arguing against a point nobody made. The article is about "creating gorgeous UI". The article is explicitly focused on making things that look good. The author does not argue this focus on aesthetics is more important than usability. (Although usability is partially a concern if you consider how much he talks about text legibility.)
I think reasonable people can agree that interfaces should be usable and beautiful. I think it is then also reasonable that someone would want to have a focused discussion on just one part of that.
A UI that's entirely functional without being flashy or visually attractive still accomplishes its mission (e.g. space shuttle control panels). A UI that's beautiful to look at but can't be understood is of little value.