Re:Twine, the Video-Game Technology for All
by A_COMPUTER on Thursday November 20, 2014 @12:15PM
(#8636791)
>Your premise requires an invalidation of modes of interactivity as meaningful.
I feel this is worded a little strongly. I alluded to the fact that even just books can have modes of interactivity, but we don't consider them games.
>then you will say that adventure games are not games, puzzle games are not games, etc.
I believe that this is where some people's intuitive sense that something isn't a game comes from.
Thanks for the link, I liked it a lot. I bob in and out of this stuff but I'm inspired to take it more seriously again.
What the critical majority is going for in their understanding of "game" is this idea of "novel interactivity" - that the author is primarily interested in the mode of interactivity, vs. communicating through an established mode like a book or song. The status quo that you're pointing to is "systemic interactivity" - the part of "game" that employs rules, player agency, and simulation. The issue with upholding systemic interactivity is that then you can reason your way into a situation where many video games are not games because on a broad level, they reach predetermined outcomes in the service of a designed story. And then you will say that adventure games are not games, puzzle games are not games, etc. There are some designers who take this kind of stance[0], but as you acknowledge, they're in the minority.
[0] http://keithburgun.net/are-games-a-storytelling-medium-guest...