News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twine, the Video-Game Technology for All by chipsy on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @10:05PM (#8634212)
Your premise requires an invalidation of modes of interactivity as meaningful. To transpose Twine works into a book is actually a considerable adaptation in many cases, because the form of discovery in Twine requires clicking hyperlinks and watching text appear or disappear - not turning pages!

What the critical majority is going for in their understanding of "game" is this idea of "novel interactivity" - that the author is primarily interested in the mode of interactivity, vs. communicating through an established mode like a book or song. The status quo that you're pointing to is "systemic interactivity" - the part of "game" that employs rules, player agency, and simulation. The issue with upholding systemic interactivity is that then you can reason your way into a situation where many video games are not games because on a broad level, they reach predetermined outcomes in the service of a designed story. And then you will say that adventure games are not games, puzzle games are not games, etc. There are some designers who take this kind of stance[0], but as you acknowledge, they're in the minority.

[0] http://keithburgun.net/are-games-a-storytelling-medium-guest...

Re:Twine, the Video-Game Technology for All by A_COMPUTER on Thursday November 20, 2014 @12:15PM (#8636791)
>Your premise requires an invalidation of modes of interactivity as meaningful.

I feel this is worded a little strongly. I alluded to the fact that even just books can have modes of interactivity, but we don't consider them games.

>then you will say that adventure games are not games, puzzle games are not games, etc.

I believe that this is where some people's intuitive sense that something isn't a game comes from.

Thanks for the link, I liked it a lot. I bob in and out of this stuff but I'm inspired to take it more seriously again.