News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by A_COMPUTER on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @09:03PM (#8633996)
So, I completely agree with this letter, but I felt a sense of unease reading it. I realized why. Other companies are as bad or worse about privacy, where are all those letters? I wish there were a lot more of these and wonder if the only reason this one exists is because the blowup with Uber was so visible and so it can be used for political posturing.
Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by snowwrestler on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @10:44PM (#8634332)
These types of letters do get sent to other companies. Here's one from Franken to some obscure app company from February:

http://www.franken.senate.gov/?p=press_release&id=2699

Here's one to Google from Markey:

http://www.washingtonpost.com/business/technology/googles-pl...

Here's one to the FTC about Facebook from Warner:

http://www.warner.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/pressreleases?...

Here's one from Schumer to Zuckerberg:

http://www.schumer.senate.gov/record.cfm?id=324221

Here's one from Blumenthal and Franken to Social Intelligence (never heard of them before):

http://www.blumenthal.senate.gov/newsroom/press/release/blum...

I found all these by Googling something like "senator letter [company name] privacy". Most don't get covered here because they are typically routine pandering by politicians that doesn't change anything. (As is this letter IMO.)

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by w4 on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @09:07PM (#8634012)
This was my reaction as well. Yes, Uber's behavior here is reprehensible. But it's also kid stuff compared to what other entities (including the Federal Government itself, whose behavior we never agreed to in a TOS agreement) are engaged in, and I have to wonder what, if any, authority the government could exert in these circumstances (disregarding the appropriateness of the use of said authority, or any potential legislative action). Assuming nothing about Uber's user terms and agreements aren't unlawful, it's almost certainly the case that, as alluded to by Franken's letter, users of Uber have agreed to provide Uber with this sort of access to their usage of the app.

So while I agree with the spirit of what Frankin is saying, I'm just left with distaste for what obvious posturing and pandering it is.

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by smt88 on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @09:22PM (#8634063)
I see what you're saying, but there are two things that make this more egregious than other (assumed) offenses.

First, Uber did this brazenly and, one could argue, openly. Their hubris needs to be curbed this way.

Second, Uber explicitly wanted to go after a member of the press. The press is our shield against all the evil that is done against the public by governments and corporations.

We need our journalists to feel absolutely safe in their chosen profession. We may disagree with or even hate some of them, but we have to show people considering such an important career that it won't put them at risk.

As far as I know, Google and other companies are using/gathering our information equally legally. They might be doing something nefarious with it, but at least they claim to be responsible and honorable. With the exception of their press releases, Uber seems proud of their ruthlessness and lack of integrity.

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by 001sky on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @10:13PM (#8634244)
First, Uber did this brazenly and, one could argue, openly

The reported quote was couched in the hypothetical; reported out of an 'off the record' private event; by a reporter that was the +1 of an invite.

Those are major caveats. While they don't excuse anything, they also (frankly) answer several of the senators questions.

I find it un-imaginable that Franken (or anyone) has never articulated views in the hypothetical, that may or may not have been in line with "corporate policy".

Imagine if the 405 freeway was mic'd during rush hour. We'd have prisons full of criminals charged with thought crimes.

All that being said, Uber needs to get its act together. Transportation is a heavily regulated industry for a variety of reasons. There are personal safety issues involved, interstate commerce, and all kinds of local issues.

Uber needs to get itself in a position where politicians and the public can trust the company to operate in a manner deserving of the public trust. And in that direction, it seems to me at least, that they are showing a pattern of behaviour that is more at issue than any single event.

It seems their general approach is open to question, on quite a few fronts. Wether or not rebellious, upstart brands are a problem, I don't think thats it. They seem to take on take on a air privledged 'bro's' who are untouchable and shady. And that is something that they don't want to be type-cast as, when ultimately their business relies on the public's trust.

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by wpietri on Thursday November 20, 2014 @02:40AM (#8634733)
> The reported quote was couched in the hypothetical; reported out of an 'off the record' private event; by a reporter that was the +1 of an invite.

The man laid out a detailed plan to harm reporters while talking to reporters. That it's hypothetical doesn't matter. If a mob boss told journalists about how easy it would be to make journalists disappear, that it was hypothetical and off the record wouldn't matter.

Senior executives of zillion-dollar companies do not accidentally talk to journalists. It could be that the guy is just a total idiot. But when otherwise smart people do something apparently stupid that just happens to serve their interests, it's reasonable to think that it was entirely intentional.

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by yummyfajitas on Thursday November 20, 2014 @04:21AM (#8634944)
The man laid out a detailed plan to investigate and anonymously report facts about reporters while talking to reporters.

ftfy

If we want to make hyperbolic analogies, the closest one might be a mob boss suggesting hiring hit men to kill other hit men while talking to a hit man.

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by DanBC on Thursday November 20, 2014 @02:38AM (#8634726)
> The reported quote was couched in the hypothetical; reported out of an 'off the record' private event; by a reporter that was the +1 of an invite.

"Off the record" isn't some magic phrase you can use to stop a journalist from reporting what you say.

It's a carefully constructed agreement between a source and a journalist. That agreement will cover what material is divulged and how it is sourced.

It is wrong to suggest that this meeting was "off the record".

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by 001sky on Thursday November 20, 2014 @03:12AM (#8634800)
This is dis-engenuous. One of the guests invited a tabloid reporter, did not appear to disclose the terms of the invitation to this person, and the result is predictable.

The ethical nuances here are lost because you have a sketchy company and an ethically challenged publication.

But in the same vein as the Mozilla incident, freedom of the press, nor freedom of speech...does not protect a citizen from another citizen.

If a muck-raking journalist wants to hide behind ethics to keep citizens from muck-rakin them, that's simply not protected by law or frankly by any real ethical consideration, other than the sense of moral proportionality that reflects their own behaviour.

It is a bizzarre point, but unfortunately its fundamentally correct.

The only "new" ethical consideration in this flap has to do with using specific information (presumably confidential company information) to bolster an attack. From what i've read, nobody suggested that this type of attack was only possible using a certain set of information.

Notwithstanding the distastefullness here, this is simply nothing that is not done in every major national election. So in that regard, the senator could equally send such a complaint to the DNCC.

What is actually the legitimate issue here is something much narrower: whether or not a malicious person would have the potential to abuse information that is not publicly available to do this.

That is very much a legit issue, but I'd be interested to see if the actual discussion would have been so bizaerre as to require this formulation. That would bring the company and its policies into the actual discussion in a way which simply articulating that low ethical standards swing both ways does not.

For example, a malicious threat would be something along the lines of "I know where you were last weekend at xx:xx" where this information would be used to extort or blackmail someone (eg, an affair etc). This type of threat would specifically hinge on the abuse of private information. Whether or not this was somehow allowed under any user agreement or employee policy is beside the point--its blatantly an abuse of implicit trust.

That is an entirely different type of situation that saying if "reporter X" is unethica, someone might very well do the equivalent of a classified-security clearance review of "reporter X" and articulate the findings in public. [1]

Needless to say, most people that look at this cannot distinguish the two cases, or if they can they are happy to disregard the reality of how the world works already.

The second issue is the idea of proportionality. In that when faced with some level or argument or counter argument, you dis-repscet the process of discourse and engage in ad-hominem. That is to say, in this case, retaliation with character assasination.

Again, I think this cuts both ways here. Being tone deaf and lacking in porportionality is a problem for ethically challenged startups--not doubt--but its also a problem with tabloids (see: uk phone hacking) and social media lynch mobs.

[1] If it meets the test of being legal and proportionate, its not really unethical by default.

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by DanBC on Thursday November 20, 2014 @10:04AM (#8636023)
> This is dis-engenuous. One of the guests invited a tabloid reporter, did not appear to disclose the terms of the invitation to this person, and the result is predictable.

People need to realise that journalists will report everything. They will report as much as they possibly can. Unless you have a written agreement with a specific journalist that covers what is or isn't allowed to be printed you must assume that they will print everything.

The meeting was not private.

You keep saying things like "ethically challenged". That's wrong -- this is standard journalistic ethics.

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by 001sky on Thursday November 20, 2014 @01:24PM (#8637206)
That's wrong -- this is standard journalistic ethics.

That's a gutter dwelling argument that is bullshit on both-sides. Because it supports the idea that private citizens should also be free to trash journalists. After all, if they have no ethics, they have no moral high ground to use as a defense against their own tactics.

So you are arguing the point of the Uber-douche.

Nice one.

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by DanBC on Thursday November 20, 2014 @01:36PM (#8637267)
The meeting was not off the record. Don't invite journalists to a meeting and expect them to not report what you say at that meeting. If you need to go off the record you need an agreement with the journalist.

You've twisted that to suggest that journalists are the same as an Uber executive digging dirt. The difference is that the journalist publishes under their name, via an editor and publisher, and is prepared to go to jail to protect their source.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8622941

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by 001sky on Thursday November 20, 2014 @01:44PM (#8637317)
Where is your source for this? Buzzfeed guy was not an invited guest. His excuse was that, since he was not invited, he was not bound to the terms of the invitation.

As someone else has written, if you think you need a (written) contract to enforce ethics, you don't understand the concept of 'ethics'. Contracts are useful because they create legal -- not simply ethical -- obligations.

In any event, if you don't appreaciate any of this, we can agree to disagree.

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by thehammer on Thursday November 20, 2014 @08:52AM (#8635658)
"The press is our shield against all the evil that is done against the public by governments and corporations."

This seems incredibly naive to me. It's certainly idealistic, and it's extremely difficult to believe that the media, at least the American media, isn't heavily biased by capitalism. Sensationalism does more harm than good, and it's trivial to "buy" press coverage. The New York Times may very well have enough integrity to refuse to be bought, but it's a common practice to solicit journalists to write articles about new products and such. If you have an agenda, there are journalists ready to be paid to support it. Not only is the press sometimes not our shield, sometimes they're actually a sword against us.

While Travis' comments were certainly regrettable, there's an important distinction between talking about doing something and actually doing it. Almost anytime someone is called out for something they've said, the comments are taken out of context. It's easy for me to imagine that what was said was a reaction to a journalist behaving badly, writing an article with an agenda. It seems likely that the suggestion to use trip data was a suggestion to stoop to the same level, rather than simply to be evil towards someone who was noble and with unquestionable integrity. Uber gets a lot of press, and while some fair points are made, the press I've seen tends to be overly aggressive, misinformed, and usually displaying a clear agenda. What Uber is doing is revolutionary, disrupting well entrenched business models. When you disrupt an industry, you make enemies of the people who were lazily profiting from it. That doesn't mean Uber is good and their opponents are evil. But make no mistake that there is a battle going on, and ugly things are being said on both sides. We're all a bunch of idiots if we waste time letting ourselves be drawn in by someone else's agenda rather than assessing the merits of each side independently and voting with our wallets.

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by smt88 on Thursday November 20, 2014 @10:24AM (#8636128)
It doesn't matter if the press functions with 100% altruism or 100% efficiency. No body comprised of humans ever will. Of course there are capitalistic motives, and making money does often run counter to the public benefit of the press.

But there are many idealistic journalists (look at ProPublica, for many examples) who are doing important work, exposing things that aren't always sexy, but are definitely in the public's interest.

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by thehammer on Thursday November 20, 2014 @02:35PM (#8637625)
The press isn't a special case where we have to make sure they can operate without being held accountable for their actions. Everyone should be held accountable and everyone should be able to defend themselves. If anything, journalists are already granted a greater shield than the rest of us.

Again, we're talking about journalists who have _acted_ with agenda against a company, and we're up in arms over off-hand _comments_ about retaliation. Neither party is altruistic and both are financially motivated. If the press acts with agenda and now reports on the retaliatory comments that were made, they can no longer be regarded as unbiased and fair. I'm not going to take their side, and I'm certainly not going to defend them when they appear to be the real bully. Nor am I going to support Al Franken as he attempts to exploit the situation for his own benefit. We've got bigger problems to deal with than who's more butt-hurt about what someone else said.

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by craigching on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @10:00PM (#8634195)
> So while I agree with the spirit of what Frankin is saying, I'm just left with distaste for what obvious posturing and pandering it is.

At least someone is speaking up. You criticize Al Franken for not going after everyone else as well, but why not criticize the other 99 senators who haven't done anything. I apologize in advance if I'm missing another senator that has done anything like this about privacy.

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by briandear on Thursday November 20, 2014 @04:56AM (#8635037)
Rand Paul has done something far more important that weighing in on a private business policy.. He (along with a few others) have been extremely outspoken against the Patriot Act and warrantless NSA spying. Where's Franken's letter to Obama demanding "executive action" to suspend warrantless information gathering by the government. If Uner wants to be a shit, we don't have to use Uber. If I don't want my personal information harvested by my government, I have no recourse. I even live in France, yet my French bank records are required by FATCA to be disclosed to an American government entity simply because I happen to have an American passport. That's far more intrusive than anything a ride-sharing app can do to me. How about reports that the government has monitored journalists? Where's Franken's letter about that?

This is nearly meaningless political grandstanding because Uber happens to be both well-known as well as currently in the headlines.

http://www.nationaljournal.com/congress/the-nsa-has-at-least...

And here's Rand Paul proposing a bill to end warrantless NSA wiretaps. http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/rand-paul-bill-would-curb-nsa...

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by jazzyk on Thursday November 20, 2014 @01:30PM (#8637245)
100x this.
Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by rtpg on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @10:07PM (#8634219)
>But it's also kid stuff compared to what other entities (including the Federal Government itself, whose behavior we never agreed to in a TOS agreement) are engaged in,

Complaining about gov't behaviour compared to private enterprise is like complaining about how kernel-level processes can do so much more than userland processes.

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by ivanca on Thursday November 20, 2014 @02:14AM (#8634690)
No, it would be like complaining that a bug found in an userland program is publicly scrutinized but not when the same one is found on a kernel program.
Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by TeMPOraL on Thursday November 20, 2014 @05:11AM (#8635058)
One man's bug is another man's misunderstood feature. Cf. Shellshock.
Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by lmg643 on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @09:41PM (#8634133)
agreed. my first thought in reading this:

"Dear Mr. Kalanick - how dare you allow your staff to announce an idea to spy on the American people and use the information you learn against them? Didn't you know that privilege is exclusively for the US government?

You know we will partner with you to abuse the vast information available on the habits of Americans through your service when the time is right - no need to get people riled up more than they already are.

Best Regards, Uncle Sam."

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by peteretep on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @10:11PM (#8634237)
The biggest thing that will disenfranchise your political weight is dismissing the government as a homogenous mass, moving in lock-step, that "they're all as bad as each other".

Uncle Sam is _people_. Good people, bad people, influential people, less influential people.

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by quanticle on Thursday November 20, 2014 @03:36AM (#8634846)
That said, I do think it is valuable to point out that while Al Franken is admonishing Uber with one hand for tracking people without permission, he's giving the NSA pats on the back with the other for doing the very same thing [1]. If anything, the NSA tracking is worse. Uber can't send me to Gitmo, but the federal government sure can.

[1]: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/06/11/al-franken-nsa_n_34...

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by ams6110 on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @09:52PM (#8634165)
My feeling also. If this isn't a case of the pot calling the kettle black I don't know what is. The Federal government is one of the worst offenders at being careless with personal data and of using it for political purposes when it suits them. I'm not defending Uber here, but this is just grandstanding by Frankin.
Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by craigching on Thursday November 20, 2014 @12:43AM (#8634572)
> My feeling also. If this isn't a case of the pot calling the kettle black I don't know what is. The Federal government is one of the worst offenders at being careless with personal data

So all federal government is responsible for all other arms of federal government, Al Franken is a member of the federal government, therefore guilt by association?

Just a question, but are you ok with your movements being tracked by Uber? Are you ok with any corporation spying on your movements and potentially using that information against you? So because the NSA spies on you, it's not ok for Al Franken to stand up to corporate privacy issues? Just saying ...

Yes, I would like to see anyone stand up for privacy issues, corporate or federal. As has been pointed out in other threads on this post, Al Franken actually does stand against both.

So let's agree that "the pot calling the kettle black" is a bad analogy because not all federal government necessarily agrees with other arms of the federal governments' actions. Yeah?

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by mturmon on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @11:13PM (#8634403)
OTOH, Frankenstein is the chair of the committee whose job is to oversee these matters. Perhaps the Senate Intelligence committee would be the analogous thing for government surveillance: http://www.intelligence.senate.gov/memberscurrent.html
Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by mturmon on Thursday November 20, 2014 @11:19AM (#8636443)
Worst auto correct ever, btw. "Franken"
Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by spoomor on Thursday November 20, 2014 @02:11AM (#8634684)
> including the Federal Government itself, whose behavior we never agreed to in a TOS agreement

You voted for them, which is their way of saying "see, it's in the fine print, hahaha"

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by perlgeek on Thursday November 20, 2014 @03:30AM (#8634825)
Not everybody who lives in a country has the right to vote.
Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by ubernostrum on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @09:54PM (#8634174)
At the same time, we run into a problem with your unease, namely that we have to catalogue and rank by severity every privacy breach before addressing any individual one. Which is the same as saying we'll never address any.
Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by A_COMPUTER on Thursday November 20, 2014 @12:19PM (#8636820)
I'm not offering a solution, and I agree that ranking is bad. The biggest problem in all of this in my opinion is that the real criteria for this getting attention from Congress was "can I make political hay out of this." That's the worst possible metric short of active malice (although Congress does that too.)
Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by bequanna on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @09:33PM (#8634100)
In my opinion, this is simply a distraction.

Where is the outrage over Target, Home Depot, et al carelessly storing and allowing credit card information for hundreds of millions of customers to be compromised?

Where is the outrage over my landloard losing my sensitive information and having no liability if/when my identity is stolen?

Use/abuse of data by companies is nothing compared to the damage that is done when data is stored improperly. How are we allowing companies to hold so much information that is so potentially damaging to us yet not able to hold them legally/financially accountable when our data is compromised because of their negligence?

I'm not sure what it would look like, but regulation and penalties should be focused on sensitive data storage not use.

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by waterlesscloud on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @09:11PM (#8634024)
If you're a company with a lot of user data along these lines, this letter serves as notice that you'd better be able to answer these questions for your own company. Who knows when The Eye will glare your way?
Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by travisp on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @10:10PM (#8634231)
>Who knows when The Eye will glare your way?

It seems like arbitrary application of political power in this way is more likely to increase political lobbying dollars than anything (make The Eye glare a different way or get your competitor).

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by w4 on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @09:14PM (#8634032)
> Who knows when The Eye will glare your way?

It never will - Franken loses his chairmanship of the committee come January when the Republicans take power, which only serves to highlight that this "investigation" is merely him pandering to his constituency on his way out.

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by somebehemoth on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @09:41PM (#8634132)
Franken has been consistent in his support of privacy. Last year, he wrote to Tim Cook requesting clarification of Touch ID's details of implementation:

http://www.franken.senate.gov/?p=press_release&id=2562

"... that this "investigation" is merely him pandering to his constituency on his way out."

An alternative, and more likely, explanation is that he is just being consistent in representing his constituency throughout his career.

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by waterlesscloud on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @09:18PM (#8634046)
The subcommittee, which is specifically tasked with looking at tech privacy issues, isn't going away.
Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by revscat on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @09:57PM (#8634182)
No, but it will certainly be rendered useless by a majority party which believes government should have no meaningful say in any decisions made by businesses.
Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by freshflowers on Thursday November 20, 2014 @02:28AM (#8634711)
Because Uber isn't part of the SV crowd that works with the US government in it's push against privacy, unlike for instance Google and Facebook, who regularly work together with the US government to pressure entire nations into removing their privacy related civil rights protection.

Uber is not (yet) on the inside, and its brazen, undiplomatic and downright stupid behavior is an embarrassment and a liability for those who work to destroy privacy quietly.

A backlash against Uber might escalate into a broader backlash, and that makes a lot of people very nervous.

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by rayiner on Thursday November 20, 2014 @08:23AM (#8635544)
> if the only reason this one exists is because the blowup with Uber was so visible

If you're a U.S. senator, you're probably not all that plugged-in to what various companies are doing with privacy. Heck, I'm constantly learning new things: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8634687.

> and so it can be used for political posturing.

So? You're unlikely to be able to build-up the mindshare to tackle an industry-wide problem without meaningful high-profile examples. Uber happens to make a particularly good one: they have a "God Mode" where they can see everyone's physical location! Quite a bit more visceral than uploading your e-mail address to Facebook and following you around with 1x1 pixel images.

Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by wpietri on Thursday November 20, 2014 @02:37AM (#8634725)
An effective free press is part of the foundation of democracy. From my perspective, this is as bad as Uber going after politicians, regulators, or activists. Other companies may be as bad, but I don't think their badness is as dangerous.
Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by Shivetya on Thursday November 20, 2014 @05:32AM (#8635117)
Uber has more public exposure, and perhaps as Apple learned before them as did Google, you need members of Congress. Sometimes they remind you of that subtlety, other times not so much; legislation.
Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by nativexer on Thursday November 20, 2014 @01:38AM (#8634659)
Letters like this appear all the time but only when the issue is sensationalized. It's inconsistent and doesn't actually solve any root problems between technology and society.
Re:Senator Al Franken's Letter to Uber [pdf] by puredemo on Thursday November 20, 2014 @02:47AM (#8634744)
Uber management was successfully trolled by the media, so now the political class is interested. Had they kept their nose down and remained silent there would be little to no outcry.