News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch by chime on Monday October 05, 2009 @09:57PM (#863317)
I'm having a very hard time believing that this is real. If it is, they have just made breakthroughs in multiple domains in computer graphics, recognition, and composition at the same time. Here's hoping it's real.
Re:This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch by NickM on Monday October 05, 2009 @10:34PM (#863373)
My guess is that it's real, but that it doesn't usually work as well as the example images provided. If it really works for any kind of input sketch, then how come there are so many images of dogs catching frisbees and bears catching fish?
Re:This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch by JacobAldridge on Tuesday October 06, 2009 @12:03AM (#863495)
Yup. When I see a real-time demonstration showing a bear catching a frisbee (probably, but not definitely, while jumping out of a shark-threatened helicopter), then I'll believe it.

Edit: I'll also believe it if anyone on this site claims to have seen same.

Re:This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch by lurkinggrue on Tuesday October 06, 2009 @01:56PM (#864760)
The algorithm is optimized for dogs/Frisbees and bears/fish.

Reminds me of a company I worked for they were working on a video compression and the video source the developers had was a security camera.

The compression was optimized for bookshelves and hand waving.

Re:This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch by albertsun on Monday October 05, 2009 @10:36PM (#863378)
The Gizmodo story says that they presented it at SIGGRAPH Asia 2009. According to http://www.siggraph.org/asia2009/ that doesn't take place until December.
Re:This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch by apu on Tuesday October 06, 2009 @12:56AM (#863554)
Papers for SIGGRAPH & SIGGRAPH Asia are accepted a few months before the conference.

These are the best two conferences in computer graphics, and the bar to get in is extremely high -- reviewers are very very tough and submitted papers have to not only be technically accurate, but also very polished in writing and presentation (and video).

That being said, a lot of these kind of systems have been coming out in the past few years, and it's a little hard to judge how successful they are due to the enormous amount of work required to reproduce results (their releasing a binary is commendable).

My own personal feeling is that this system probably works quite well for "common" things in their database, but there might be many small artifacts in generated images. Also, if you start trying to include stuff that's not well represented in the database, then the artifacts probably become quite severe.

Re:This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch by Pistos2 on Tuesday October 06, 2009 @12:33AM (#863527)
Well, it is listed here: http://www.siggraph.org/asia2009/for_attendees/technical_pap... "Friday, 18 December | 9:00 AM - 10:45 AM | Room 301/302" Not sure what to think. Maybe they're writing in past tense in the same way sports sites write "such and such team played on Tuesday" even though it was Tuesday at the time of writing.
Re:This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch by shib71 on Monday October 05, 2009 @10:04PM (#863324)
The technical terms and researcher's names pass the Google sanity check, e.g. http://cg.cs.tsinghua.edu.cn/prof_hu.htm, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kadir_Brady_saliency_detector.
Re:This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch by jerf on Monday October 05, 2009 @10:39PM (#863381)
Surprisingly, not really. Computer vision has been moving along lately. This is good stuff, but incremental progress against the backdrop of other good stuff in the field.

A few times in the past few months the question of whether "all the good stuff" has been discovered or whether there's no progress left to be made came up, and computer vision has been one of my go-to examples of a field that has just been booming lately. Interestingly, digging in shows that it's still not "AI", just as you don't see any "AI" here, but there's still been a qualitative sea change in the past few years. I think the fact that a $1000 machine is now unbelievably powerful has been a real boon for the field.

Re:This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch by joeyo on Tuesday October 06, 2009 @12:03AM (#863492)
I have seen this argument being made frequently here recently--that the "AI" that we have produced is not "real" AI. This is understandable true in a way, since after all, AIs cannot do many of the things that natural intelligences can do. And so there is this perceived disconnect between the weak AI that we have (rules, heuristics, belief networks, bayesian inference and friends) and the strong that we AI (magic?).

But there is a similar disconnect that looms between the rudimentary intelligence of simple organisms and the more sophisticated intelligence higher mammals. Many researchers have noted this taken the insight that with a simple set of rules you can get complex behavior. This has lead to something of a revolution in ML, robotics and neuromorphic engineering. If this analogy holds, then it may be that the distance between weak and strong AI will be bridged in the same way that the distance between single celled organisms and primates appears to be bridged: by iteratively building complex systems on top of simpler building blocks. There simply won't be a secret sauce to be found, but each layer of complexity will allow for increasingly sophisticated behavior.

Re:This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch by fortybillion on Tuesday October 06, 2009 @01:24PM (#864663)
When I took an AI class back in University, the professor noted that the term AI is usually only applied to the problems we can't solve. As soon as we determine an algorithm for something, they no longer call it AI.

So technically, it was a Data Mining class I guess.

Re:This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch by jcl on Tuesday October 06, 2009 @09:35AM (#864058)
This is one of those SIGGRAPH papers that are like magic tricks -- unbelievable until you find out how they're done and what their limitations are.

There are existing projects that pair an image composition function with a tagged image database (like this one: http://graphics.cs.cmu.edu/projects/photoclipart/). This project sounds like it adds a fitness function so that it can find an output image that looks good.

Re:This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch by jacobolus on Monday October 05, 2009 @10:34PM (#863372)
Most of the parts have been done (a couple things look new, but just read through the list of SIGGRAPH papers for the last few years; the field is sprinting forward, as computers become fast enough to do this sort of computation), but putting it all together is pretty damn impressive.

Now, as hard as what's been done on the algorithms side, someone has to figure out a usable user interface for these tools, so that regular people can play with them.

Re:This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch by fname on Monday October 05, 2009 @10:01PM (#863320)
I agree... But they have the source available if you can get to the site. Otherwise, here's the Google cache link:

http://74.125.95.132/search?q=cache:http://cg.cs.tsinghua.ed...

Re:This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch by patio11 on Monday October 05, 2009 @10:20PM (#863355)
The download doesn't include source.

It does include 5 executables totaling ~140k. I am not quite brave enough to run them but I did run them through strings, and a cursory inspection suggests either that they're either attempting to do what they're claimed to do or they're the best disguised malware in history.

Re:This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch by uiohnuipb on Tuesday October 06, 2009 @10:59AM (#864262)
So gentlemen our plan is simple. We study computer graphics for 10years, get PhDs, develop a system that gets headlined at siggraph, become famous and - then we release a binary that the HN readers will download.

World domination is in our sights <evil laugh>

Re:This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch by anigbrowl on Monday October 05, 2009 @10:58PM (#863413)
Oh the software's legit - I ran them all and nothing bad happened :) It's just not very stable or easy to get going with, is all.
Re:This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch by joe_the_user on Tuesday October 06, 2009 @02:52PM (#864907)
"Real" is relative. It might be "real" for a set of a hundred images but it might seriously bog-down or spit-out garbage if you tried to implement it for ten thousand, never mind ten million.

Image processing is full of things that sort-of work, that are impressive but not fully reliable.

Re:This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch by NathanKP on Monday October 05, 2009 @10:33PM (#863371)
We've been seeing some pretty fascinating developments in graphics and pattern recognition recently. A few days ago someone submitted that amazing Photoshop plugin that allows you to select a region and move it around seamlessly, and also fill in areas seamlessly. The demo showed the software filling in the broken areas of the Pantheon and the results were quite impressive. A combination of both technologies would be simply incredible.

Edit

The official site of the plugin is definitely down. Its probably overloaded by all the people who are interested in checking it out. ;)

Re:This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch by anigbrowl on Monday October 05, 2009 @11:21PM (#863439)
Just FYI, that stuff to which you refer is a teaser for CS5, the next iteration of Photoshop...due around April, most likely.
Re:This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch by fortybillion on Tuesday October 06, 2009 @01:31PM (#864682)
The SIGGRAPH presentation video for this is here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dgKjs8ZjQNg
Re:This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch by ja2ke on Tuesday October 06, 2009 @01:52AM (#863626)
Siggraph is home to some crazy presentations. I'm always surprised by the more impressive videos and papers, but on the other hand, never that surprised, just because it's always only one step crazier than the crazy thing from last year's.
Re:This Is a Photoshop and It Blew My Mind - Photosketch by jeremyawon on Tuesday October 06, 2009 @03:01AM (#863699)
the automated object recognition and extraction is what impresses me. everything else is a killer usage example of that core technology.