News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Trends: Uber vs. Lyft by yummyfajitas on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @03:23AM (#8628861)
Ok, lets roll with your idea that anonymously publishing true information is unethical.

If a woman blogged unkind and sexist behavior at a tech company, but hid her name to avoid the backlash (like Michael), that would be unethical. I guess she'd be an "asshat", right? Same thing for a journalist using an anonymous source?

Bad journalistic ethics? https://modelviewculture.com/pieces/that-time-i-was-caught-c...

I do indeed have a poor understanding of ethics and I'm pretty open about it. It's hardly an easy subject. Often I think I've found the "critical element" and suddenly swapping around the personalities radically changes my intuition.

Re:Trends: Uber vs. Lyft by eksith on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @03:33AM (#8628883)

  If a woman blogged unkind and sexist behavior at a tech company, but 
  hid her name to avoid the backlash (like Michael), that would be 
  unethical. I guess she'd be an "asshat", right? Same thing for a 
  journalist using an anonymous source?
Did you just compare a woman blogging about a legitimate grievance that makes her work environment intolerable to someone suggesting "Fair game" practices a la Scientology for criticizing his company?
Re:Trends: Uber vs. Lyft by yummyfajitas on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @03:43AM (#8628913)
Yes. That's what makes ethics hard.

According to alex, the "critical difference" is anonymity. On this dimension, the sympathetic figure and the big jerk do not differ. So if he is correct about anonymity, then they are indeed comparable. The point is to test whether he really believes his stated principle or whether it's merely a convenient justification to criticize big jerks that he dislikes.

If you think that's not right, that's fine. Then come up with your own principle separating Emil Michael's journalism proposal from Pando/Valleywag. I'll repeat this exercise - trying to come up with a sympathetic figure on the other side of your principle and see if you still support the conclusions.

That's how you test whether your ethical principles are really valid.

[dead]
Re:Trends: Uber vs. Lyft by yummyfajitas on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @04:02AM (#8628967)
Have you considered the possibility that I merely didn't completely understand everything you said? You mentioned ethics repeatedly in your post, so I thought your "critical difference" referred to ethics rather than merely the definition of journalism.

I thought the you said anonymity was the critical point making it unethical (given your reference to "journalistic ethics". Now it sounds like you merely meant that it doesn't fit some definition of journalism. Is that right?

So would a fair characterization of your beliefs would be that Michael's proposal would be ethical (much like the anonymous hypothetical woman I mentioned, or the real anonymous woman I linked to) but not journalism?

Or is it unethical for some reason that you didn't mention?

Re:Trends: Uber vs. Lyft by DanBC on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @04:38AM (#8629055)
> Have you considered the possibility that I merely didn't completely understand everything you said?

You post history is anti-woman in any discussion about women. Thus your attempts to reframe a CEOs speculation about anonymously attacking a female journalist's (and her family's) privacy as "journalism" after she criticises her company is unlikely to be a misunderstanding about ethics.

When a journList talks about your company the correct responses are:

i) ignore it

ii) rebut it

iii) use the complaints process or law to correct defamation

The option

iv) secretly investigate the reporter and her family to discredit her

... is clearly, unambiguously, the action of a fucking asshole.

You should find it troubling that your hatred of women forces you into supporting possibly criminal behaviour of fucking assholes instead of just accepting that this one time this woman is right.

Re:Trends: Uber vs. Lyft by yummyfajitas on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @05:03AM (#8629129)
I have no idea why you think my post history is "anti-woman" or that I hold "hatred of women". I think many of the arguments pushed by people who self describe as "pro-woman" are nonsense, but that's not the same thing.

...the action of a fucking asshole...

Contrast with what I said: "are we simply engaging in internet mobbing because...the CEO is kind of a jerk?"

Unless the anonymous woman I described (and the anonymous writer at modelviewculture) is also a "fucking asshole", the "secret" part of investigating the reporter is not a problem. So investigating and reporting is "possibly criminal"? Assuming there is something more here than mobbing someone you dislike, I truly do not understand it.

Re:Trends: Uber vs. Lyft by DanBC on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @08:41AM (#8629911)
> I have no idea why you think my post history is "anti-woman"

You have never, ever, taken the side of a woman in any HN discussion.

Whatever the situation you will always find some way to criticise the woman, even if it requires you to distort facts and construct wierd hypotheticals.

Re:Trends: Uber vs. Lyft by yummyfajitas on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @11:03AM (#8630730)
You have never, ever, taken the side of a woman in any HN discussion.

Easy enough to refute: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7539622 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7539709

That discussion is almost the opposite of this one - the author spurred negative emotional reactions, but I defended her due to her careful definitions and reasoning.

This one also defends a specific human: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7312188

As samreidhughs points out, you are incorrect in this claim for a second time. My mistake, I remembered that comment, didn't remember it was you who made it.

I pretty rarely defend a person of any gender, however. Most of my comments tend toward abstraction. I barely view the comments I've made here as defending Uber, and more as simply advocating against mobbing.

Re:Trends: Uber vs. Lyft by SamReidHughes on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @09:37AM (#8630217)
Weird hypotheticals are a standard practice in philosophy.

Also, 'yummyfajitas criticizes or disagrees with male people all the time too. It's only natural, if you omit vapid posts of agreement from your repertoire, that you're always going to be seen disagreeing with and criticizing people.

Edit: Oh, I see that you've made these inane responses to yummyfajitas before. We can see an analog in your past comment:

> You don't create as much discussion going the other way - there are no posts from you askng why society accepts most corporate boards having no women or asking why society accepts discrimination against people with Arab sounding names. All your questions are about why it's okay to discriminate against white males in these kinds of programmes.

And yummyfajitas's reply:

> No one on HN is defending discrimination against people with Arab sounding names.

Perhaps the same sort of observation might be found on this axis of discussion?

And this isn't the first time you've made some metacommentary aboutq yummyfajitas's posting history. This time it's "hatred of women", last time it was racism. What are you gonna try next time?

Re:Trends: Uber vs. Lyft by alexqgb on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @04:19AM (#8629012)
No fajitas, it did not occur to me that you were incapable of interpreting a basic English sentence with a clearly defined subject and modifier, and that you'd resolve your confusion by fishing around for words scattered elsewhere in the post to fill in the blanks.

But the point, again, is that you described what the Uber exec proposed as "hiring journalists to do journalism to journalists." And the point you missed is that what he was describing was manifestly not journalism, for reasons I went on to describe.

There are several other reasons why his line of thought was hugely unethical, but those are separate issues, and given your tendency to put words in the mouths of others, that's not a conversation I'm willing to have with you.

Re:Trends: Uber vs. Lyft by dang on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @04:34AM (#8629046)
Please stop.
Re:Trends: Uber vs. Lyft by Centigonal on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @03:22AM (#8628856)
Your points are totally valid, and I agree with you insomuch that I think the comment you replied to is a poorly-informed work of reductionism, but you're being very abrasive yourself as well.

You practically gave your parent commenter a verbal beat-down over his grasp of journalistic ethics. The guy said a bunch of mostly wrong things, but he made a few good points, too!

Re:Trends: Uber vs. Lyft by alexqgb on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @06:30AM (#8629415)
Sorry. For what it's worth, it wasn't his poor grasp of journalistic ethics that attracted my opprobrium. The sharply negative reaction was prompted by the general dishonesty of his remarks and specifically his tendency to reframe the remarks of others in a way that egregiously misconstrued or misrepresented what they had to say.
Re:Trends: Uber vs. Lyft by dang on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @04:02PM (#8632599)
I'm afraid this is a non-apology that does the same thing all over again.

Let's suppose you're 100% right. Please don't squander that rightness on pejorative epithets and personal attacks. Doing so is wrong, breaks the HN guidelines, makes you look like the jerk in the argument, and makes your position seem weak. That last point is a big deal: since by hypothesis you're right, roiling the waters like this impedes the pursuit of the truth for everyone.

Instead, identify what's wrong and point it out clearly without personal attacks. That's easier said than done, of course, but by hypothesis it has to be possible, and it's your duty to honest readers to try.

Re:Trends: Uber vs. Lyft by alexqgb on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @05:22PM (#8633067)
Fair points, duly noted.
Re:Trends: Uber vs. Lyft by DanBC on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @04:13AM (#8628999)
If you hate yummyfajitas you should probably ignore his posts. Your answers deserve down votes and flags.

Especially calling someone a "blithering idiot" is clearly agInst guidelines.

If you think he's said something flag-worthy or downvote worty just flag it or downvote it and ignore it.

Re:Trends: Uber vs. Lyft by wutbrodo on Wednesday November 19, 2014 @03:23AM (#8628859)
Yeesh I agree with your comment overall but what's the point of making it 50% ad hominem?