Re:Did The Harappan Civilization Avoid War for 2,000 Years?
by cw0 on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @01:16PM
(#8625311)
I had the same thoughts as you while reading the article and I can only imagine you are being downvoted by nationalists who aren't happy at the suggestion that the Harappans weren't writing Sanskrit epics on their pots.
Re:Did The Harappan Civilization Avoid War for 2,000 Years?
by jkaunisv1 on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @03:00PM
(#8625969)
After reading your profile, I don't think people are disagreeing with your statement :) Personally I've just started noticing your name above comments and enjoyed every one as thoughtful and stringently logical.
AFTER EDIT: As usual, I would be happy to hear a rationale for the disagreement that is evidently being expressed regarding this comment. Please show your capacity to teach me (and onlookers) something. I'll mention here that I have studied a variety of other languages (those are disclosed in my Hacker News user profile), including Chinese, and I have made specialized study of the origins of writing around the world. That's my basis for judging the plausibility of various claims about the ancient Harappan inscriptions. A book on that topic I highly recommend, because it is written by very knowledgeable historical linguists, is The World's Writing Systems, edited by Peter T. Daniels and William Bright. There has been a little bit of new work on Harappan inscriptions since that book was published, with several claims and counterclaims by competing scholars, but no settled demonstration that the Harappan inscriptions are writing at all, and certainly no settled demonstration of what they are writing about, if anything (as the article submitted here acknowledges).
[1] http://www.amazon.com/Worlds-Writing-Systems-Peter-Daniels/d...