News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GNU Guix 0.8 released by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @10:04AM (#8624098)
> Package management is probably, today, a very well defined problem.

I don't think it is. I think "package management" is a name for a general class of solutions that addresses a range of problems (varying, at a minimum, along a continuum between "I want a way to pull a set of implementations of particular capabilities on any of a variety of different systems for which the appropriate implementations of those capabilities may be different" to "I want be able to reproduce from a list the same set of implementations across different machines".)

There's also a range of priorities about certainty of results versus freedom to mix and match and ease of contributing to the globally accessible repository.

I very much don't think the problem addressed by package management is "well-defined", and I'm not even sure it is coherent in the sense that were the problems different people look to package management to solve all collected, there would be a single workable solution that would address all of them optimally.

Re:GNU Guix 0.8 released by stinkytaco on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @12:46PM (#8625116)
The imperfect analogy I've used is the comparison between paints and pencils. They perform similar general functions (placing something on a media) and even use a similar set of tools (a long stick held in the hand). But the end result and even the goal could be totally different (I may want to hang a painting on a wall in a frame and I may want my pencil drawings to be reproduced a book).

It's not perfect, but it helps non-users (i.e. managers) understand that one tool does not fit all.