For the record, I believe that the BSD and MIT license allow the distributor to withhold source from me, which does "hurt" me from my point-of-view.
As an example, How many chemistry and biology lab machines have you seen running windows 95 or dos because the company won't release updates for old software and want you to buy a new machine?) I've seen many, and it's very difficult and expensive to keep them running at times because they don't work under emulation for various reasons.
No, it pretty much does: http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/freedom
It's true that too much freedom can produce awful results but let's not redefine the word?
To reference Erich Fromm, its not about "freedom to", but "freedom from". If you modify or distribute a work based on a copyleft work, you have "freedom from" being sued for patents, DRM, or proprietary copyright restrictions. If the work was based on a permissive licensed work, no such freedoms are given. You only have freedom to distribute the original work or modifications of it.
Personally, I'm happy for others to use most of my code without contributing back. Does that therefore mean that you and I have different definitions of the word "freedom"?
If so, then why isn't that in the dictionary? Do we need separate dictionaries?
Freedom to, and freedom from, both include the word freedom. They share philosophical ideas, most which originate from the ancient Rome. The question we are having is how to solve the paradoxes which said philosophy created.
I thus personally prefer to use the word liberty rather than freedom. Liberty is commonly understood to have a philosophical connotation, while freedom is more associated as mechanical concept. A slave can reach freedom by running away, but to gain liberty, they got to be given rights.
(Not to imply that BSD isn't granting some liberties. It is. The above is about the word freedom.)
It seems your analogy is a wee bit overwrought.