Re:OSIRIS spots Philae drifting across the comet
by ChuckMcM on Monday November 17, 2014 @01:55PM
(#8619762)
This is my understanding from reading the web site and some of the proposal papers associated with the mission.
The plan was that Philae would come in at net 0,0 velocity with respect to the normal of the landing site. That involved putting it into an orbit which intercepted the landing site. This was made a bit more challenging as the top thruster on Philae failed to fire, which meant it was unable to circularize its interception orbit. And that resulted in some horizontal motion at the time of landing.
That said, the motion seems to have been well within the safely margin of the harpoon system from what I can read about that subsystem.
Since we aren't on the comet we can only guess what happened but one speculation I've read that seems plausible is that the harpoons "fired" but did not "release", which is to say they tried to move and did not. Imparting a delta-v that was vertical with respect to the surface normal of the landing spot. That delta-v, combined with the landers imperfect alignment, contributed to the sideways journey.
It did confirm that you really do want something like harpoons to hold you to the comet (and potentially to asteroids if you're doing missions to them).
The plan was that Philae would come in at net 0,0 velocity with respect to the normal of the landing site. That involved putting it into an orbit which intercepted the landing site. This was made a bit more challenging as the top thruster on Philae failed to fire, which meant it was unable to circularize its interception orbit. And that resulted in some horizontal motion at the time of landing.
That said, the motion seems to have been well within the safely margin of the harpoon system from what I can read about that subsystem.
Since we aren't on the comet we can only guess what happened but one speculation I've read that seems plausible is that the harpoons "fired" but did not "release", which is to say they tried to move and did not. Imparting a delta-v that was vertical with respect to the surface normal of the landing spot. That delta-v, combined with the landers imperfect alignment, contributed to the sideways journey.
It did confirm that you really do want something like harpoons to hold you to the comet (and potentially to asteroids if you're doing missions to them).