News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Still Here, Part 1: A Memoir by ivanca on Sunday November 16, 2014 @10:22AM (#8614374)
Yes it is. Psychotic and mental illness are very serious issues, and trivializing them as caused by "masculinity" is as sick as it gets.
Re:Still Here, Part 1: A Memoir by wpietri on Sunday November 16, 2014 @11:24AM (#8614568)
Is your claim that there is zero correlation between violence and culturally constructed notions of masculinity? Or that there is no relationship between guns and cultural notions of masculinity?

Because both of those things seem obviously wrong to me. For example, I love "guy movies" with guns and explosions and macho nonsense. But it is enormously gendered. Take the movie Salt, where Angelina Jolie played the sort of role typically reserved for guys. There was enormous discussion about having a woman in a role like that. The script was substantially reworked because a woman took the title role. Neither would have happened if this stuff weren't heavily gendered.

Also, psychosis is very serious, but are you really asserting that all mass shooters were experiencing psychotic breaks at the time of their actions? I've only seen a couple of psychotic breaks up close, but those poor people hardly seemed capable of planning the purchase of a happy meal, let alone making and and carrying out a carefully crafted, months-long plan to murder a bunch of people.

Re:Still Here, Part 1: A Memoir by ivanca on Monday November 17, 2014 @06:50PM (#8621576)
>Is your claim that there is zero correlation between violence and culturally constructed notions of masculinity?

No, my claim is that is phisically impossible to distinguish between society pressure and testosterone combined with a chemical imbalance.

When I was a teenager I have had desire to end it all in the same way that many shooters did, you know why? Is not about "masculinity", is about hatred for everything that breaths, for not fitting into society and the complete lack of social skills that I supposed I was too stupid to learn or that society didn't teach me. There is a lot going on in our body when you are going through puberty, testosterone, loneliness, discomfort, confusion, extreme self-consciousness, a lot of stuff besides "masculinity". So yeah, Annita and people should STFU about things they don't start to understand.

Re:Still Here, Part 1: A Memoir by wpietri on Friday November 21, 2014 @06:59AM (#8640866)
As a person who was also once a teenager with testosterone, puberty, loneliness, etc, I disagree on a few points.

First, I disagree that the loneliness, etc, doesn't have a lot to do with our culture's construction of masculinity. There's a lot of stuff that boys are "supposed" to be that plays into that. We're supposed to be tough, macho, and unfeeling, so we don't get much support for expressing or managing those emotions. We're supposed to "win", to be dominant, to be high status, with no help if we don't. We're not supposed to talk about the details of social interaction the way that girls do, so it's always more mysterious. We are discouraged from building social and emotional support networks. And there's a whole host more. It has taken me literally decades to start seeing how poisonous so much of that early gender programming was for me.

Second, I disagree that having been through it once makes you such an authority that you get to tell everybody else to shut up. Fishes undeniably understand water. But so do chemistry professors and hydrodynamicists. There are different ways to understand something.

Third, I disagree Anita and David Futurelle and I "don't start to understand". I think I understand my past as well as you understand yours. I'm sure David feels the same way about his past. Both Futurelle and I have also spent years examining the mechanisms of gender culture. And for us, Anita's point is accurate. Which is unsurprising to me, because she literally has a degree in this stuff. Her Master's thesis was on gender representations in SF&F TV.

Now that doesn't mean she (or anybody) is automatically right. But she does have standing to talk.

Re:Still Here, Part 1: A Memoir by geographomics on Sunday November 16, 2014 @10:26AM (#8614382)
Why do you claim that this is trivialising mental illness? The potential influence of culture on mental health is surely a topic of some pertinence and interest.
Re:Still Here, Part 1: A Memoir by delecti on Sunday November 16, 2014 @03:22PM (#8615297)
As a general rule, men are much more reluctant to get help with mental illnesses, largely as a direct result of toxic masculinity.
Re:Still Here, Part 1: A Memoir by ivanca on Sunday November 16, 2014 @03:39PM (#8615349)
How do you conclude is thanks to "toxic masculinity"? And not something else? BTW the slipery slope in such term is revolting, otherwise can you give me an example of common toxic femininity?
Re:Still Here, Part 1: A Memoir by delecti on Sunday November 16, 2014 @06:14PM (#8615927)
Toxic femininity isn't really a thing, but the other side of the same coin would be societal pressures on women's appearances, and pressures to not be a slut/prude/bitch.

Also, I think you need to explain what slippery slope you mean.

Re:Still Here, Part 1: A Memoir by ivanca on Monday November 17, 2014 @06:53PM (#8621584)
Re:Still Here, Part 1: A Memoir by delecti on Monday November 17, 2014 @07:34PM (#8621769)
The idea of toxic masculinity is that it's a set of negative behaviors among men that are reinforced by other men. "Toxic Femininity", if it existed, would have to be a set of behaviors reinforced by other women, so the "disposable male" idea wouldn't really qualify as part of it.

Also, the idea of the disposable male is a bit misleading, because it really only applies to less privileged men, barring exceptions like "women and children first" on a sinking ship, which really is another example of toxic masculinity anyway.

Re:Still Here, Part 1: A Memoir by ivanca on Monday November 17, 2014 @08:05PM (#8621860)
Yeah, everything is just the fault of males, they are the only ones reinforcing gender stereotypes. Yes, of course, you are so right.
Re:Still Here, Part 1: A Memoir by delecti on Tuesday November 18, 2014 @06:36PM (#8627123)
This is a discussion about toxic masculinity, which is a set of social constructs enforced by men upon men. Of course women are part of reinforcing gender stereotypes, it's just a separate issue.

The idea is that if there weren't social pressures enforcing gender roles, then lots of negative social aspects of masculinity could go away, and men wouldn't be shunned as elementary school teachers, or discouraged from seeking help for emotional issues. I don't understand why anyone would be against that, and I also don't understand why you're resorting to such argumentative replies.