News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Culture is not about esthetics (2011) by eli_gottlieb on Saturday November 15, 2014 @05:03PM (#8612783)
>The main points of the article, as I understand it, are that society shouldn't encourage the creation of new art, because we already have more than enough good art to last anyone a lifetime, and because artists are mostly motivated by social status anyway.

How about, because new art is often created to fill the particular desire of an actually-existing person rather than to feed gwern's smug sense of superiority to the rest of humankind. And let us add, people create art because it's fun, which is reason enough for almost anything.

And then there's the issue with citing Robert "capital-accumulation is ethical value" Hanson on, well, anything.

Re:Culture is not about esthetics (2011) by JamesArgo on Friday November 21, 2014 @02:11PM (#8642755)
>To feed gwern's smug sense of superiority to the rest of humankind

Really?

>And let us add, people create art because it's fun, which is reason enough for almost anything.

He's arguing against subsidising art, not for stopping all art production.