Re:Should the United States Declare Books an ‘Essential Good’?
by javert on Saturday November 15, 2014 @04:03AM
(#8611259)
If someone pays for a book, that person wanted the book.
That is the only kind of "good" there is.
You are correct that new books are not intrinsically good because there is no such thing as intrinsic good, ever.
That view is based on invalid philosophical theories.
Thanks, Plato.
Re:Should the United States Declare Books an ‘Essential Good’?
by NeverEnough on Saturday November 15, 2014 @11:13AM
(#8611947)
I believe they mean good as in a consumer good, not a moral good.
that is, how should this good be taxed, is it something essential like food that should carry a low tax rate?
That probably leaves the question about books that become "accidental hits" or "sleeper hits". But even then, this discounts aren't going to completely wipe them out and I would believe that these sorts are the exception rather than the norm. Again, there are simply so many new books published all the time, and very little of it can possibly be good.
Gwern has some good thoughts that I feel are relevant:
http://www.gwern.net/Culture%20is%20not%20about%20Esthetics