Re:The Endlessly Examined Life: A most chronic depression
by csdrane on Friday November 14, 2014 @05:26PM
(#8609886)
Sad story. I wonder whether he might have benefitted from a mindfulness based therapy. Unfortunately, some depressions are more difficult to treat than others. Very qualified doctors that I know would disagree with the notion that "itβs still not clear that [antidepressants] are better than placebos." They would argue that antidepressants are overprescribed to people that do not in fact have biological depression, lowering the effectiveness rate. Lastly, it should be noted that ECT (electroconvulsive therapy), is actually one of the most effective treatments for depression, and one that carries minimal harmful side effects (although short-term memory loss is one such side effect).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Endlessly Examined Life: A most chronic depression
by quanticle on Friday November 14, 2014 @06:02PM
(#8610055)
As someone with depression, it's clear to me that our knowledge of mental health is where medicine was in the late 1700s. We know that certain treatments work for certain people, in certain situations, but we don't have the theoretical frameworks to figure out where to experiment further. Reading the psych. literature, it really feels like a lot of the science in that field is just random shots in the dark. When certain therapies or substances work well, we don't why they work and in what circumstances they won't.
IMHO, psychology is still waiting for its "germ theory" moment.
Re:The Endlessly Examined Life: A most chronic depression
by marincounty on Friday November 14, 2014 @10:43PM
(#8610764)
I'm so tired I'm not even sure why I'm posting. I have
spent so many days thinking about the treatment of
psychiatric disorders; it literally gives me a headache.
I agree that Psychiatry is still in the Dark Ages(not figuratively, but in some ways so close to the right period
in time it's humorous.) I won't state what I was diagnosed with, but what I will disclose is it came on one Christmas
Eve and went on for Years. I tried all the tri, and heterocyclic drugs. They all failed spectacularly. The
only reprieve I have gotten over the years are highly addictive drugs. I now just try to keep the dosage low because I know if my current doctor retires; I'll have a
hard time getting these drugs, or run out of money paying out of pocket for unnesarry office visits. I don't blame
the Psychiatrists--that is the Psychiatrists who don't call
themselfs "Specialist in Psychotropic Drugs", or a dude who
charged $400.00/hr for dubious advice and medication. Who
I do blame are the Drug companies and their oh so carefully
designed Double Blind Placebo Controlled studies. Studies
which were pimped out to the cheapest Ho(country). Studies
that were cherry picked in order to show the FDA their dubious drug worked slightly over Placebo. Studies that didn't exclude early Placebo responders. Studies that didn't account for subjects who felt the side effects and attributed to the Placebo Cure. And--my last gripe; Studies
that didn't really use subjects who were clinically ill.
Yes--they were poor, and many times Homeless, but they really didn't have a malfunction in their brain.(Yes--they
might have had symptoms out of DSM-5, but because of their
predicament many of their symptoms could be accounted for.)
While I'm on the soap box, I'll pass this along. I'm not
sure this s the truth, but it came from a good source. It
is this; I was told that Fluoxetine(Prosac) showed so little promise it was "shelved" for years until some MBA
in Business decided to he could market a cureall drug--that
is if the researchers played along?
Re:The Endlessly Examined Life: A most chronic depression
by Hydraulix989 on Friday November 14, 2014 @08:39PM
(#8610531)
ECT offers a very poor trade-off -- potentially irreversible brain damage and mental dysfunction in exchange for the docility and temporary emotional blunting or euphoria that result from the damage.
Re:The Endlessly Examined Life: A most chronic depression
by rhizome on Friday November 14, 2014 @10:39PM
(#8610760)
Yep. It's "effective" in that it's not suicide.
Re:The Endlessly Examined Life: A most chronic depression
by DanBC on Saturday November 15, 2014 @02:02AM
(#8611080)
No, it's effective in that it cures completely some people's depression, leadig to a transformed life.
Not everyone, and it's reserved for long term untreatable severe depression, but it's important to note that it's very effective for some people.