This is because things you choose to wear are fashion choices, and the whole reason people choose one fashion over another is to make a statement about who they are.
In this respect, Glass is no different than regular glasses; all regular glasses serve the same functional purpose of correcting impaired vision, but a pair of (say) Warby Parkers also make a particular statement about the personality of the person wearing them.
The chasm Glass has fallen into is that the fashion meaning of a particular thing is decided collectively by the culture, not by the people who created it. And the culture has collectively decided that the fashion statement Glass makes is "I am a turbo nerd."
It felt more like this odd space where I wasn't sure what the socially appropriate behavior was. More than anything else it was like talking to someone with an obvious disability, where there are delicate social conventions around when to acknowledge or not acknowledge it. Sort of like a glass eye. Except that here it was deliberately installed, and not related to an injury or disability. It particularly disoriented me with regards to eye contact. I constantly felt like I was supposed to make eye contact with him rather than staring at his facial device, which took conscious effort to do. But at the same time, I found myself frequently trying to discern whether he was making eye contact with me or rather was looking at the display in the glasses. The normal eye-to-eye gaze part of conversation was completely disrupted for me. I find smartphones much less disorienting simply because it's much more obvious when someone is looking at the screen vs. at you, which simplifies the social conventions. So to me as the "other party" in a conversation, the HUD form-factor is a downgrade in functionality from a handheld screen.
Glass (rightfully or not) has come to stand for both useless trinkets for the tech-wealthy and pervasive surveillance of the masses by a large corporation, so wearing it really comes off as saying "I have more money than you and I'm going to use it to let Google record videos of you too!"
A camera-less Google Glass at a lower pricepoint would simply say "I am a turbo nerd" and would probably be much more acceptable.
So my Glass goes unused, because I don't feel comfortable wearing it anywhere.
Moot now if you're not using it, but you know, even if your tape was as big as a golf ball, as a passerby I'm not going to know or think that your camera is covered, because I avoid looking anywhere near the things. And for all I know it could be a hardware hacked version with the camera hole elsewhere. So your goal was not being achieved. And it still might be recording audio. If you're wearing it, I have to take your word for it. If you're not, I don't.
Am I crazy for finding the smartphone form ideal? I want something I can fit in my pocket easily, take it out quickly and casually as many times as needed, but mostly it should be put away.
Are these $1500 glasses fragile? Can they be put in a pocket or will they break without a case? How big is the case? Likely much larger than a smartphone. I always have to be responsible for those glasses when I'm not wearing them one way or another.
I'm not interested in increasing the amount of time I spend online, just the convenience. Glasses won't solve that. I won't even be willing to use contacts when they're available in that form.
I think they missed the market a bit - don't target the tech-fashion group with a device like that. Wait until you can get something actually slick. Something fashionable with some nice transition lenses for that market.
The spartan, minimalist headband-with-a-computer on it device? Market that thing at sporty types. Runners, hikers, cyclists. A lightweight hybrid of a GoPro and a smartwatch that's hands-free? People could look past battery, price, and fashion issues for that, and lots of extreme-sports-types already do wearable cameras.
But it's incorrect to assume that this thing being "weird" is the only reason to make people hostile. I myself would be hostile to someone wearing that stuff, not because I'm some swain who never saw a computer, but exactly because I know what it is, I know which company made it and what that company does, I know about their business model and remember all these stories about them grabbing WiFi traffic from years ago and all the other things that make them "evil" in some way. And I see you as this company's drone for filming and recording audio around you all over the world, and not some weirdo who spends $1.5K on useless things. The fact that it's you who pays $1500 to be the drone isn't the reason for someone like me to be hostile, it's just funny.
(My immediate impression of the wearer, for the record, was that he was likely a director of an oil-related company looking to show off his wealth.)
Yet... I personally think they launched without a killer app. Comparing against headphones, listening to music in a portable and private manner was novel and a "killer app." To your point, today's mobile devices cover off on a wide range of capabilities, and my sense is that Glass hasn't provided an app that was "killer" enough to overcome the stigma and eventually erode it.
Didn't help that a large % of the fashion-conscious out there felt it was ugly as sin. I wouldn't be surprised if it takes Apple to wearables sexy and acceptable. They are smart to start with a watch since the form factor is understood and not dramatically different.
The killer app, the one that will override peoples fears (by praying on them) is 24/7 recording to the cloud. The first mugging/assault that is foiled (or perpetrators caught) cause their faces and actions were streamed realtime to not personal storage will get every paranoid parent and frightened wealthy person wanting one.
It would be really good for dealing with police officers who go around destroying phones and other similar situations, so it wouldn't be completely useless either.
"Strange Days" explored that topic way ahead of its time, especially in the opening. (Cut away the "fry the brain"-stuff)
As others have pointed out, the cost of using Glass is high, and I'm not just talking about the monetary cost. There's a social cost as well, as lots of people will stop you in public to have a conversation about Glass. Most of them are just curious, but I've encountered my fair share of people who are judgement or even overtly hostile. (I live in SF, which is a fairly forward-thinking city, so I imagine it was worse for people in other areas.)
Based on my experiences, it seems that when you merely possess technology, people tend to acknowledge and refer to it distinctly. However, when you wear technology, people increasingly conflate you and your character with the technology itself. The difference between walking around with a phone in your hand and walking around wearing Glass is the difference between carrying a tube of paint and painting your face green.
In my opinion this was predictable and Google should have anticipated it. (This is why studying psychology is important.) They should've focused on giving early Explorers an "excuse" to wear Glass, but they did the opposite. Ideally, we could've presented ourselves by saying, "I'm wearing this because I'm a tester. Want to try them on?" Instead, more often than not, conversations would begin with the other party saying, "So you paid $1500 for these?" That's not a great starting point in any way, shape, or form.
I've heard that things were similar when headphones first started catching on for mainstream use. The difference is that headphones were worth the cost. By contrast, the incremental improvements that Glass makes over a smartphone aren't worth the social/physical costs of wearing something on your face.