News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Glass future clouded as some early believers lose ... by AndrewKemendo on Friday November 14, 2014 @03:25PM (#8609290)
As someone in the AR space, even I wouldn't use glass, BUT it has been amazing for getting the word out about what AR is and that has been invaluable. Instead of having to explain to people what AR is, all I have to say is "You know google glass?" and they immediately get it.

I think there are a couple of big problems with glass:

1. It doesn't do AR substantively, which is the breakthrough feature, instead its basically just a semi-transparent floating screen

2. Its got a photo taking camera on it*

3. Interacting with it is cumbersome/clunky

To do 1 effectively, it needs to be full field of view or at least the bulk of the FOV, which is a major issue with lenses that close to the eye and why I think they acquired Magic Leap.

2 is a fairly simple fix but would need a whole new re-branding and google may have burned this bridge already.

3 is really a tough thing to figure out but I think could be done with CV gestures that aren't physical touch based, but rather view orientation based. So for example if you look down, you immediately get your apps displayed and you can use your hand to select/type in a similar form function as people do now with phones.

*I make the distinction about photo taking because if the camera was only used for CV/tracking on device and had no "photo taking" feature, people would be less worried about it. And yes I am aware that images are still taken, its the distinction in what is happening by default that the public in general cares about.

Re:Google Glass future clouded as some early believers lose ... by waterlesscloud on Friday November 14, 2014 @03:31PM (#8609313)
To me the fact that it doesn't really do AR is the major problem. It only does what my phone does, with a slightly more convenient interface. It really needed a whole new set of features and benefits, not just somewhat improved versions of the existing mobile ones.
Re:Google Glass future clouded as some early believers lose ... by Pxtl on Friday November 14, 2014 @04:51PM (#8609707)
I think hands-free access to your phone's screen could have been sold to athletes and people who work with their hands. But that didn't need a camera and certainly isn't worth $1500.
Re:Google Glass future clouded as some early believers lose ... by noamyoungerm on Friday November 14, 2014 @03:40PM (#8609359)
It's very much a prototype project. The primary benefit is not so much in the product itself but rather that it makes the new concept viable and ready to exploit.

It's not that different from the first iPhone, which was really just a touch screen media player with a phone antenna.

Re:Google Glass future clouded as some early believers lose ... by waterlesscloud on Friday November 14, 2014 @05:59PM (#8610035)
True enough. And I realize we're a ways off from full AR, just for hardware reasons. But some token gestures in that direction would have helped. Something to show the promise.
Re:Google Glass future clouded as some early believers lose ... by grayclhn on Saturday November 15, 2014 @02:56AM (#8611159)
Except that the first iPhone was massively popular.
Re:Google Glass future clouded as some early believers lose ... by scoot on Friday November 14, 2014 @03:50PM (#8609410)
> 2. Its got a photo taking camera on it*

In terms of social acceptance, that was probably mistake # 1.

Most of the negative stories have been about the potential abuse of the camera. If glass had been launched primarily as an AR device, then, once normalized, the camera could have ben introduced as an upgrade.

Re:Google Glass future clouded as some early believers lose ... by alexbecker on Friday November 14, 2014 @06:40PM (#8610205)
This has always seemed a little strange to me. Why is having a camera bad? I walk around with a camera attached to my face all day, just like everyone else. I don't see how having an electric camera is that different. Sure, I guess I can show a picture rather than explain it, and offer proof instead of my word, but neither of these differences seem substantial enough to explain the animosity I've seen.
Re:Google Glass future clouded as some early believers lose ... by fl0wenol on Friday November 14, 2014 @10:58PM (#8610785)
Are you trying to be dense?

The issue is an always-on-esque digital camera permits you to make a permanent record with limitless distribution anything you saw with your eyes in a way that isn't potentially falliable like an anecdote is, and you can share it with everyone and anyone at any time.

Most people out in public do not want this to be the case at your personal discretion.

Re:Google Glass future clouded as some early believers lose ... by ZenoArrow on Saturday November 15, 2014 @11:01AM (#8611917)
Try watching this video (it's not too long, roughly 8 minutes)... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ziHCvpikLh8

What do you think about it?

To me, yes, the storyline is dramatised, but the core concept is real. One of the key problems of technology like Glass is that it creates another barrier in direct human interactions. That is why, personally, I'd prefer for it to be limited in use rather than ubiquitous.