News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Dream Stack - Is This A Joke? by jrockway on Sunday October 04, 2009 @04:43PM (#860599)
Note the byline: "Senior Analyst, Forrester Research".

To non-programmers like the author, this sort of article is reasonable. Programming is not a creative art, it's just about buying some tools that you read about in the trade magazine.

Re:The Dream Stack - Is This A Joke? by gaius on Sunday October 04, 2009 @05:15PM (#860640)
Unfortunately the reality is that some poor coders will be lumbered with whatever the CIO read about in a Forrester report. The article itself counts as "research".
Re:The Dream Stack - Is This A Joke? by nopassrecover on Sunday October 04, 2009 @09:52PM (#860946)
While I agree with your sentiment I'm not sure if that's definitely the case.

First, when you have an average level of programmer (as the sort of corporations that would hire a senior analyst tend to), selecting the right tools is where you can innovate against your competition.

Second, if this wasn't written by a non-programmer, but instead was an Ask-YC "What stack would you use to build the next Google/Facebook/Amazon etc." I don't think this same criticism would be levelled at the author.

Re:The Dream Stack - Is This A Joke? by jrockway on Sunday October 04, 2009 @11:06PM (#861072)
Wouldn't you want to hire a senior programmer to make programming decisions?
Re:The Dream Stack - Is This A Joke? by nopassrecover on Monday October 05, 2009 @12:39AM (#861226)
I'm not sure I get your point in relation to mine, can you elaborate?
Re:The Dream Stack - Is This A Joke? by jrockway on Monday October 05, 2009 @07:02AM (#861563)
I thought you were suggesting hiring analysts to fix the problems that the amateur programmers created. But now that I re-read your post, it seems like you are just observing how the industry works.

Honestly, I think we should feed "analysts" as much bad data as possible so that the companies that rely on analysts are killed off. The analysts will then die too :) (Have you ever poisoned someone to cure their cold? This would be like that. Kill the host, then the virus dies :)

Re:The Dream Stack - Is This A Joke? by nopassrecover on Monday October 05, 2009 @06:47PM (#863005)
I have to admit I've never poisoned someone to cure their cold.
Re:The Dream Stack - Is This A Joke? by jrockway on Monday October 05, 2009 @10:11PM (#863335)
It's 100% effective!