News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Mercenaries: Ex-NSA hackers are shaping the future of... by snlacks on Thursday November 13, 2014 @02:07PM (#8603386)
Sounds like part of my summary's issue was grammar/word choice. I definitely understand the problem now and will be more careful.

New summary: The governments (plural) hire these companies (as opposed to "guys") and may, but don't always, keep these software vulnerabilities secret in order to collect information on people/targets. This is sometimes done with a warrant and in other times is done without the need.

I don't see how the governments and these companies aren't keeping the vulnerabilities in the software we rely on secret, I need more convincing.

I really appreciate you taking the time to flesh it out with me, even though it's unlikely we'd end up agreeing (just from hints in the tone we're using), I'm glad it won't just be over poor writing on my part. Thanks!

Re:The Mercenaries: Ex-NSA hackers are shaping the future of... by tedunangst on Thursday November 13, 2014 @02:31PM (#8603522)
Yes, the vulnerabilities are kept secret. The value of an exploit decreases significantly after the vulnerability is patched, and they are in the business of selling high value exploits. If they couldn't sell the exploits, they wouldn't be finding the vulnerabilities either. Banning exploit sales won't suddenly result in VUPEN turning into a vuln finding charity.

For whatever it's worth, zeroday exploits are rare in practice. The vast majority of exploited systems are taken down with public vulns because they weren't patched in time. Very few organizations are interested in specific targets; carpet bombing the internet and searching for unpatched shellshock/drupal/etc installations will collect enough low hanging fruit.

Re:The Mercenaries: Ex-NSA hackers are shaping the future of... by snlacks on Thursday November 13, 2014 @03:19PM (#8603787)
If the NSA buys an exploit in Windows, does the NSA's contract preclude VUPEN from selling that exploit to Microsoft?
Re:The Mercenaries: Ex-NSA hackers are shaping the future of... by tedunangst on Thursday November 13, 2014 @07:24PM (#8605092)
Presumably. If you're paying for an unpatched vuln, you don't want to get a patched vuln.