News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Simple Revision Control by pothibo on Thursday November 13, 2014 @11:13AM (#8602267)
For those of you brave souls who downvote me. I'm wondering which part of my statement you disagree with.

- You think homosexual are pedophiles?

- It's not important what he thinks about homosexuals. You're going to support him by using his software.

If he had held the same hate speech about women in 2014, everyone would be here talking how imbecile this guy is.

Re:Simple Revision Control by fetbaffe on Thursday November 13, 2014 @12:02PM (#8602582)
You know, the world does not consists of two opposing positions, like republicans or democrats. There could actually be other positions than those two you pointed out. One for example that this is Hacker News and not Huffington Post.

Your comment about "support him by using his software" is just silly.

Lots of creators in this world have had less than flattering opinions in different topics, but does not take away what they produced.

I can still enjoy Wagner regardless of his views on the jews. I don't have to reformat all my ReiserFS based hard drives after Reiser murdered his wife. And The Pianist by Roman Polanski is an absolute masterpiece, even though Polanski raped that poor girl.

So I evaluate SRC based on merits, not the creators.

Re:Simple Revision Control by icebraining on Thursday November 13, 2014 @12:17PM (#8602661)
In general, I agree. The question is whether you're helping promote the "bad parts" by promoting the good ones. I mean, why are we reading and discussing ERS's views on Catholic priests if not because many people like his software?

I don't think it's fair to dismiss it as silly.

Re:Simple Revision Control by fetbaffe on Thursday November 13, 2014 @12:27PM (#8602717)
But by your definition you are already promoting other peoples opinions by using their stuff. It is unavoidable.

The only difference is that you don't care about those opinions because either you don't know about them or you don't think it is important. But they still exist.

Re:Simple Revision Control by edwintorok on Thursday November 13, 2014 @11:29AM (#8602379)
People can have different political, religious, etc. views than you, but why should that influence whether you use his software or not?

Do you check the political views of all authors of each software before you decide to use it? What if those views (or your own) change over time and you disagree with them?

Re:Simple Revision Control by icebraining on Thursday November 13, 2014 @12:05PM (#8602595)
(ESR aside) Why not? If I believe that someone's exposed views are harmful, doesn't it make sense to avoid increasing his/her overall influence?

I mean, the fact that we're discussing ESR's views on pedophilia shows that his influence in an unrelated area (software) increases the exposure of those views. If he was just a nobody like me, would we be discussing his blog post on Catholic priests? Not likely.

Do you check the political views of all authors of each software before you decide to use it?

I sure don't, but why does that mean one should actively ignore gained knowledge?

Re:Simple Revision Control by 7952 on Thursday November 13, 2014 @02:03PM (#8603364)
Maybe we respond more to the milieu of a comment more than its actual content. Personally I like conspiracy theories about topical things. I never believe them but they make me chuckle to see the world from a weird point of view. But some people are going to find such theories to be horribly offensive (like Buzz Aldrin about moon fakery). We all have the capacity to wrongly analyse something we don't understand and have no stake in. A lot of people don't know what it is like to be attracted to their own gender and come out with things that are not just offensive but blatantly silly. The rest of us no better.
Re:Simple Revision Control by edwintorok on Thursday November 13, 2014 @12:12PM (#8602629)
First of all it would take too much time to find out all the authors of all the software that I routinely use, and then keep up with what their current views are on various topics.

But I think the main reason is that most software has more than one author, and it would be unfair to judge the usefulness of that software based on the (non-technical) views of just one of its authors.

Your reasoning would apply only for single-author software, and TBH I would consider those pet-projects anyway, and I don't think the original author would care much whether you use it or not.

Edit: about gained knowledge: I think you could apply this if you compare multiple competing solutions, one deciding factor could be the author's thoughts on various topics. Just like how a company's attitude towards various topics might be influencing your purchasing decision: for example Nvidia doesn't support open-source drivers, hence I don't buy Nvidia when choosing a graphics card.

But again for me those are all technical reasons, I wouldn't factor an author's/company's political views into that decision, unless it was something really horrible.

Re:Simple Revision Control by icebraining on Thursday November 13, 2014 @12:32PM (#8602753)
Your reasoning would apply only for single-author software

But doesn't that fit SRC itself?

But again for me those are all technical reasons, I wouldn't factor an author's/company's political views into that decision, unless it was something really horrible.

Ah! But then you're not arguing whether it makes sense to factor the political views in the decision - what you're actually arguing is that ESR's views are not really horrible.

But since pothibo supposedly considers them really horrible, it makes sense that (s)he would factor in those views, no?

Re:Simple Revision Control by edwintorok on Thursday November 13, 2014 @01:03PM (#8602944)
Maybe, although I don't think I made technical decisions based on unrelated events. The closest that comes to mind is as described here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8602582 I did use ReiserFS in the past, and I did switch to something else but the reason was purely technical: XFS became quite good on a HDD, an ext4 very nice on an SSD, and also there didn't seem to be much development done upstream once the original author was gone.
Re:Simple Revision Control by plikan13 on Thursday November 13, 2014 @12:31PM (#8602746)
Why not respond to bigotry with love, instead of hating back? This is not some zero-sum game. If anyone needs a little bit of success in life, it's a bigot.
Re:Simple Revision Control by jude- on Thursday November 13, 2014 @04:37PM (#8604284)
Tolerating intolerance is not an act of love, but of apathy--both towards the bigot, and the bigot's targets.
Re:Simple Revision Control by sampo on Thursday November 13, 2014 @01:11PM (#8603007)
> People can have different political, religious, etc. views than you, but why should that influence whether you use his software or not?

It would be difficult to use software written by a person who openly had a political view that supports owning slaves.

Re:Simple Revision Control by pothibo on Thursday November 13, 2014 @01:27PM (#8603096)
This is not some mundane left wing vs right wing discussion. It's a guy who believes that homosexuals should be taken on the same level as pedophiles. The line between saying this and saying homosexuals should go to prison is thin at best.
Re:Simple Revision Control by wolfgke on Thursday November 13, 2014 @11:53AM (#8602509)
> For those of you brave souls who downvote me. I'm wondering which part of my statement you disagree with.

This part:

> I want to have absolutely nothing to do with such a degenerate.

Re:Simple Revision Control by gonzo on Thursday November 13, 2014 @12:08PM (#8602603)
ESF is degenerate.

That you choose to support him says more about you than esr, or OP.

Re:Simple Revision Control by sampo on Thursday November 13, 2014 @01:18PM (#8603044)
> If he had held the same hate speech about women in 2014

The same hate speech about gays in 2014, in Western Europe, would also be widely condemned.

Re:Simple Revision Control by dubfan on Thursday November 13, 2014 @11:21AM (#8602320)
Maybe people are downvoting you because you're showing an incapability to distinguish between someone's expressed beliefs and their personal character?
Re:Simple Revision Control by astrodust on Thursday November 13, 2014 @11:30AM (#8602383)
Aren't those two a little intermingled?

"Apart from the fact that he hates Jews, he's a really nice guy!"